More actions
4 February 2024
→Biography
+12
Putting this aside for now (because I have more important things to do), my point on this citation being backwards still stands
Undo revision 3702024 by BananaClownMan (talk) I encourage you to scroll down the page you're citing here. It is not the case that we simply cite the first time things are referred to. See, for instance, the citing of 'The mission was thus regarded as the "first shot" of the War. ' This issue is so notable that there is an ONGOING FORUM THREAD ABOUT IT. - Forum:Etc. vs et al.
+54
As explained before, it is not a violation of T:NPOV (removing the novelisation entirely would be a violating T:NPOV), I am just editing the same way one does with any other account by listing the origin of the information; example, we don't cite every mention of the Time War on Last Great Time War, we just cite the first time any development is mention, mostly the various outcomes. (Also, you put the last citation backwards, the TV one would have gone first)
−54
1 February 2024
Undo revision 3700526 by BananaClownMan (talk) I didn't say it did, you misread me completely. The policy that requires us to do so is T:NPOV.
+54
As explained elsewhere, Thread:231243 does not give cause the ciliate the same information twice, just to accept novelisations as a valid source of reference.
−54
Premised on outdated view of how novelizations are handled. It is indeed a violation of T:NPOV.
+54
11 January 2024
7 January 2024
No breach of T:NPOV. Just keeping the adaption exclusive information cited differently to avoid confusing readers on what came from where, as is done with every information exclusive to an adaptation (otherwise, why not cite both at the bottom?)
−98
This information is also present in the novelisation. T:NPOV. All sources have equal weight.
+98
→Biography
−94
5 December 2023
→Biography
+1
no edit summary
+301
no edit summary
+1
no edit summary
+408
Aquanafrahudy moved page Singh (The Star Beast) to Shervan Singh
mno edit summary
+54
no edit summary
+728
2 December 2023
1 December 2023
25 November 2023
no edit summary
+24
no edit summary
+38
no edit summary
m−3
Adding categories
+71
Created page with "{{Infobox Individual |image = |alias = |species = Human |affiliation = UNIT |origin = Earth |only = The Star Beast (TV story) |actor = Ronak Patani }} ''' Major Singh''' was a UNIT officer. (AUDIO: ''The Star Beast'') {{NameSort}}"
+313