Talk:Music of the Spheres (TV story): Difference between revisions
m (Talk:Proms Cutaway moved to Talk:Music of the Spheres: Broadcast name) |
(Rationale removal) |
||
| Line 10: | Line 10: | ||
According to the Proms site, the Doctor Who Prom is being recorded for BBC one. As such, I would expect it to air on BBC one, not BBC four. Taras | According to the Proms site, the Doctor Who Prom is being recorded for BBC one. As such, I would expect it to air on BBC one, not BBC four. Taras | ||
:Yes, I think someone just assummed that the BBC4 programme (which is showing the proms) would also show the doctor who scene. [[User:Jack's the man|Jack's]] [[User talk:Jack's the man|the]] [[Special:Contributions/Jack's the man|man]] - 11:10, 26 July 2008 (UTC) | :Yes, I think someone just assummed that the BBC4 programme (which is showing the proms) would also show the doctor who scene. [[User:Jack's the man|Jack's]] [[User talk:Jack's the man|the]] [[Special:Contributions/Jack's the man|man]] - 11:10, 26 July 2008 (UTC) | ||
==Rationale removal== | |||
I know it's bad form to remove rationales from the Discontinuity section, but the one that was there regarding the canonicity of the story didn't make sense and was incorrect. The fact the Graske appeared in an SJA episode has no relevance over whether ''this'' mini-episode is canonical. And yes of course Daleks Master Plan is canon even though the Doctor wished the viewers a Merry Christmas halfway through. However just as Attack of the Graske is not considered canon because it involved interaction with viewers, so too does Music of the Spheres fall into the same category. Ask yourself this: does it stand on its own without the audience interaction? It does not because if you watch the YouTube version you don't hear the audience replying to him. [[User:23skidoo|23skidoo]] 18:25, 27 July 2008 (UTC) | |||
Revision as of 18:25, 27 July 2008
Special or Cutaway?
RTD seems to be moving towards calling it Proms Cutaway - he indicates this in DWM and Outpost Gallifrey's news page is also using this title. Should this article also be retitled accordingly? 23skidoo 01:37, 11 July 2008 (UTC)
- I think Move it to Cutaway Dark Lord Xander 02:25, 11 July 2008 (UTC)
- I selected this title baed on Children in Need Special, but I don't mind either way Jack's the man - 14:28, 11 July 2008 (UTC)
Ok If no one minds I'll Move It (I can always be moved back if theres a problem) Dark Lord Xander 00:32, 12 July 2008 (UTC)
TV Broadcast
According to the Proms site, the Doctor Who Prom is being recorded for BBC one. As such, I would expect it to air on BBC one, not BBC four. Taras
- Yes, I think someone just assummed that the BBC4 programme (which is showing the proms) would also show the doctor who scene. Jack's the man - 11:10, 26 July 2008 (UTC)
Rationale removal
I know it's bad form to remove rationales from the Discontinuity section, but the one that was there regarding the canonicity of the story didn't make sense and was incorrect. The fact the Graske appeared in an SJA episode has no relevance over whether this mini-episode is canonical. And yes of course Daleks Master Plan is canon even though the Doctor wished the viewers a Merry Christmas halfway through. However just as Attack of the Graske is not considered canon because it involved interaction with viewers, so too does Music of the Spheres fall into the same category. Ask yourself this: does it stand on its own without the audience interaction? It does not because if you watch the YouTube version you don't hear the audience replying to him. 23skidoo 18:25, 27 July 2008 (UTC)
