Talk:Doctor Who - Series 9 (soundtrack): Difference between revisions
NewbPrimian (talk | contribs) (Created page with "For "The Shepherd's Boy", since the theme was originally called "Breaking the Wall" by Alastair King in his arrangement "World Enough and Time" concert, should we title the ar...") |
NewbPrimian (talk | contribs) No edit summary |
||
| (One intermediate revision by the same user not shown) | |||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
"The Shepherd's Boy" title | |||
For "The Shepherd's Boy", since the theme was originally called "Breaking the Wall" by Alastair King in his arrangement "World Enough and Time" concert, should we title the article "Breaking the Wall" and list "The Shepherd's Boy" as an alternate title? It seems that "Breaking the Wall" can be used as the name of the ''theme/leitmotif'', while the ''track'' on the album is titled "The Shepherd's Boy" (a la "A Good Man?" - the theme - appearing in other tracks, such as "Hello Hello" and "Do You Really Believe in Santa?" Similarly, the alternate version of the "Breaking the Wall" theme appears later in the scores of "The Doctor Falls" and "Twice upon a Time", so keeping the more general title may help to include these versions if/when they are released. | For "The Shepherd's Boy", since the theme was originally called "Breaking the Wall" by Alastair King in his arrangement "World Enough and Time" concert, should we title the article "Breaking the Wall" and list "The Shepherd's Boy" as an alternate title? It seems that "Breaking the Wall" can be used as the name of the ''theme/leitmotif'', while the ''track'' on the album is titled "The Shepherd's Boy" (a la "A Good Man?" - the theme - appearing in other tracks, such as "Hello Hello" and "Do You Really Believe in Santa?" Similarly, the alternate version of the "Breaking the Wall" theme appears later in the scores of "The Doctor Falls" and "Twice upon a Time", so keeping the more general title may help to include these versions if/when they are released. | ||
For now, I'll use "Breaking the Wall" as the blanket title for the leitmotif page, since the release of that performance via YouTube is official and predates this album. | |||
- NewbPrimian (27 April 2018) | |||
Latest revision as of 15:42, 27 April 2018
"The Shepherd's Boy" title For "The Shepherd's Boy", since the theme was originally called "Breaking the Wall" by Alastair King in his arrangement "World Enough and Time" concert, should we title the article "Breaking the Wall" and list "The Shepherd's Boy" as an alternate title? It seems that "Breaking the Wall" can be used as the name of the theme/leitmotif, while the track on the album is titled "The Shepherd's Boy" (a la "A Good Man?" - the theme - appearing in other tracks, such as "Hello Hello" and "Do You Really Believe in Santa?" Similarly, the alternate version of the "Breaking the Wall" theme appears later in the scores of "The Doctor Falls" and "Twice upon a Time", so keeping the more general title may help to include these versions if/when they are released. For now, I'll use "Breaking the Wall" as the blanket title for the leitmotif page, since the release of that performance via YouTube is official and predates this album.
- NewbPrimian (27 April 2018)
