Theory:Doctor Who television discontinuity and plot holes/Resolution (edit)
Revision as of 16:24, 11 April 2023
, 11 April 2023no edit summary
DiscoDave101 (talk | contribs) No edit summary |
No edit summary Tag: visualeditor-wikitext |
||
| (8 intermediate revisions by 7 users not shown) | |||
| Line 11: | Line 11: | ||
*A dalek has no emotions except for hate and fear. How then can it laugh? | *A dalek has no emotions except for hate and fear. How then can it laugh? | ||
::It has been established previously that Daleks should not have a concept of Beauty or mercy but ''[[Asylum of the Daleks (TV story)|Asylum of the Daleks]]'', ''[[The Big Bang (TV story)|The Big Bang]]'' and ''[[The Witch's Familiar (TV story)|The Witch's Familiar]]'' revealed flaws in that. Plus, perhaps the Twelfth Doctor's encounter with Davros meant he imprinted more than just the aforementioned onto the man and his creations. | ::It has been established previously that Daleks should not have a concept of Beauty or mercy but ''[[Asylum of the Daleks (TV story)|Asylum of the Daleks]]'', ''[[The Big Bang (TV story)|The Big Bang]]'' and ''[[The Witch's Familiar (TV story)|The Witch's Familiar]]'' revealed flaws in that. Plus, perhaps the Twelfth Doctor's encounter with Davros meant he imprinted more than just the aforementioned onto the man and his creations. | ||
::: This Dalek was created long before the Twelfth Doctor came into being. | |||
::::: They mean when 12 met child Davros. Which was before any Daleks were created, why is why mercy was inadvertently imprinte | |||
* If technology of the 9th century can disable a Dalek why is the Doctor so anxious about it being in the 21st? | * If technology of the 9th century can disable a Dalek why is the Doctor so anxious about it being in the 21st? | ||
::The Daleks are still a threatening menace to defeat + it's implied it took the combined forces of three empires to defeat it (given were told at least three nations were involved in taking it down.) Further, the Doctor appears more concerned with the Dalek contacting off-world Daleks to launch an invasion more than the threat the sole Dalek can produce. | ::The Daleks are still a threatening menace to defeat + it's implied it took the combined forces of three empires to defeat it (given were told at least three nations were involved in taking it down.) Further, the Doctor appears more concerned with the Dalek contacting off-world Daleks to launch an invasion more than the threat the sole Dalek can produce. | ||
| Line 21: | Line 24: | ||
*If this is supposed to be one of the earliest Daleks to leave Skaro, why is it designed like a recent Dalek? | *If this is supposed to be one of the earliest Daleks to leave Skaro, why is it designed like a recent Dalek? | ||
**Because Chibnall shows no respect for canon. This is a good point. Also it should not be able to fly. | |||
***We have never seen a recon Dalek before so it's reasonable to assume it possesses a different design and capabilities. Further, the comment about Chibnall is not needed. | |||
::::: Any comment about Chibnall pushing discontinuity is needed | |||
*How can the dalek obtain all the technology it requires from a Sheffield junkyard? | |||
**It doesn't the Dalek is shown raiding a security archive that had access to alien tech. | |||
* When the doctor realizes what they discovered in the sewers, she says "there's been a Dalek buried on earth since the 9th century." Mitch then asks, "a what?" and Graham replies "an alien psychopath" describing what a Dalek is. But Graham hasn't met any Daleks yet. He shouldn't know what they are any more than Mitch does. | |||
:: It's feasible that the Doctor merely told Graham about the Daleks, or that he had encountered them in some as of yet unseen adventure. Or maybe Graham actually remembers one of the several past invasions that the show is really inconsistent about. | |||
::: If Graham remembered, Mitch should have. The only other explanation is your "it happened off-screen" hand wave, which isn't disprovable, but would also be highly inconsistent with previous introductions of companions to recurring villains. | |||
[[Category:DW TV discontinuity]] | [[Category:DW TV discontinuity]] | ||