User:SOTO/Forum Archive/Inclusion debates/@comment-28743561-20191009174707/@comment-33695797-20191012215743: Difference between revisions
(Bot: Automated import of articles) |
m (Bot: Automated text replacement (-'''User:(SOTO/Forum Archive)/(.*?)/\@comment-([\d\.]+)-(\d+)/\@comment-([\d\.]+)-(\d+)'''\n([\s\S]*)\[\[Category:SOTO archive posts\]\] +\7\2/\4-\3/\6-\5)) |
||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
As I see it, this is a re-telling of the same story, but with different actors. The narrative is exactly the same, but that doesn’t mean it’s the same episode. This new version had a completely different production. The difference between this and an animated remake such as ''[[The Power of the Daleks (TV story)|The Power of the Daleks]]'' or ''[[Shada (TV story)|Shada]]'' (referring to the Fourth Doctor animation) is that nothing from the original production was used (e.g. the audio in this case). It is not an attempt to "fix" a missing story from its remains but to recreate it entirely. So, I believe this remake should have its own page. I also think having a separate page would be ''less'' confusing, because otherwise it could seem the two versions are exactly the same in all ways. Plus, there are a LOT of new people who worked on the 2019 version that need to be credited in either case, and it would be confusing to have two actors for the same character on the page for a single episode. | As I see it, this is a re-telling of the same story, but with different actors. The narrative is exactly the same, but that doesn’t mean it’s the same episode. This new version had a completely different production. The difference between this and an animated remake such as ''[[The Power of the Daleks (TV story)|The Power of the Daleks]]'' or ''[[Shada (TV story)|Shada]]'' (referring to the Fourth Doctor animation) is that nothing from the original production was used (e.g. the audio in this case). It is not an attempt to "fix" a missing story from its remains but to recreate it entirely. So, I believe this remake should have its own page. I also think having a separate page would be ''less'' confusing, because otherwise it could seem the two versions are exactly the same in all ways. Plus, there are a LOT of new people who worked on the 2019 version that need to be credited in either case, and it would be confusing to have two actors for the same character on the page for a single episode. | ||
<noinclude>[[Category:SOTO archive posts]]</noinclude> | <noinclude>[[Category:SOTO archive posts|Inclusion debates/20191009174707-28743561/20191012215743-33695797]]</noinclude> | ||
Latest revision as of 14:25, 27 April 2023
As I see it, this is a re-telling of the same story, but with different actors. The narrative is exactly the same, but that doesn’t mean it’s the same episode. This new version had a completely different production. The difference between this and an animated remake such as The Power of the Daleks or Shada (referring to the Fourth Doctor animation) is that nothing from the original production was used (e.g. the audio in this case). It is not an attempt to "fix" a missing story from its remains but to recreate it entirely. So, I believe this remake should have its own page. I also think having a separate page would be less confusing, because otherwise it could seem the two versions are exactly the same in all ways. Plus, there are a LOT of new people who worked on the 2019 version that need to be credited in either case, and it would be confusing to have two actors for the same character on the page for a single episode.
