Talk:Last Great Time War: Difference between revisions
Line 8: | Line 8: | ||
== When did the war happen == | == When did the war happen == | ||
I have just gotten back into Dr. Who. | I have just gotten back into Dr. Who. Watched it as a kid on PBS and now that Scifi has it, I have gotten back in. In whatch many old episodes i saw the time lords still alive and have yet to figure out when the time war happened. Can any one tell me at least what Dr. fought in the war I know it had to be the 7th to 4th, but want to narrow it down. | ||
:The Time War happens off screen at some point after the [[Doctor Who (1996)]] film with Doctor number 8 and [[Rose (TV story)]] at the start of the revived series with doc number 9 - it has not yet been shown on TV, just something that is reffered to. | :The Time War happens off screen at some point after the [[Doctor Who (1996)]] film with Doctor number 8 and [[Rose (TV story)]] at the start of the revived series with doc number 9 - it has not yet been shown on TV, just something that is reffered to. It's not entirely clear what happens in it as a result. [[User:Jack's the man|Jack's]] [[User talk:Jack's the man|the]] [[Special:Contributions/Jack's the man|man]] - 23:57, 29 December 2008 (UTC) | ||
Hello, | Hello, | ||
I must ask this question. Why does this article suggest the doctor implied he played a great part in the Time war(sourcing Dalek) then suddenly following up that he only suggested it because the Beast called him killer of his own kind(Satan Pit). These two episode are not related and did not even happen to the same doctor. | I must ask this question. Why does this article suggest the doctor implied he played a great part in the Time war(sourcing Dalek) then suddenly following up that he only suggested it because the Beast called him killer of his own kind(Satan Pit). These two episode are not related and did not even happen to the same doctor. | ||
Doctor Who IX didn't imply a major role, he outright states he watched the ship burn, then stresses that he made them burn. This does not say implication to me. | Doctor Who IX didn't imply a major role, he outright states he watched the ship burn, then stresses that he made them burn. This does not say implication to me. | ||
Line 22: | Line 22: | ||
In essence, I think this article needs to be cleared up in that respect. | In essence, I think this article needs to be cleared up in that respect. | ||
Also I don't know how cannon a comic book store is to the overall story of the Doctor. I have doubts about the peace treaty that allowed the Doctor to take the Master's remains from Skaro. If you watch the movie, you see that the Daleks judge the Master for all his evil crimes...almost as if they were acting as fair and impartial judges, strange when the Master has worked with them. I think some of the movie is confusing enough without mixing in questionable cannon of comic books. That, however, is mere opinion. | Also I don't know how cannon a comic book store is to the overall story of the Doctor. I have doubts about the peace treaty that allowed the Doctor to take the Master's remains from Skaro. If you watch the movie, you see that the Daleks judge the Master for all his evil crimes...almost as if they were acting as fair and impartial judges, strange when the Master has worked with them. I think some of the movie is confusing enough without mixing in questionable cannon of comic books. That, however, is mere opinion. | ||
[[User:Tekphoenix|Tekphoenix]] 03:20, 31 December 2008 (UTC)Fola[[User:Tekphoenix|Tekphoenix]] 03:20, 31 December 2008 (UTC) | [[User:Tekphoenix|Tekphoenix]] 03:20, 31 December 2008 (UTC)Fola[[User:Tekphoenix|Tekphoenix]] 03:20, 31 December 2008 (UTC) | ||
Line 36: | Line 36: | ||
[[User:Assassin of death|Assassin of death]] 13:57, 8 June 2009 (UTC) | [[User:Assassin of death|Assassin of death]] 13:57, 8 June 2009 (UTC) | ||
Assassin of death | Assassin of death | ||
Hi, | |||
I have always believed that as the first mention of the actual time war seems to be in the 9th doctors series that either the 8th Doctor (Paul Mcgann) or the 9th Doctor took place in the time war, though I;'m not sure if the time or Doctor has actually been decided yet. That my view anyway, thanks for listening. | |||
== Where did the pic in this article come from? == | == Where did the pic in this article come from? == |
Revision as of 18:26, 15 June 2010
According to an issue of Doctor Who Adventures, in the comic, the Doctor said that nearly every species was part of the Time War (although not at the same time and not for the whole of the Time War, I think only the Daleks and Time Lords were in the Time War for the whole war). I'm usure where to put this infomation. anyone?---Si http://images.wikia.com/tardis/images/e/e4/Si_HTL_Seal_Leader.PNG 16:57, 19 May 2007 (UTC) All the species were involved, sure, because they're all involved in time. Not all species fought, however; take the Sontarans, for instance.
Is there any information as to which Doctor was involved in the Time War? I'm assuming it was the Eighth Doctor, unless he regenerated before the Time War. 82.46.190.172 01:29, 7 July 2008 (UTC)
Could someone remove the obvious vandalism here? I would, but I don't even watch Dr. Who.98.201.35.10 00:20, 7 June 2008 (UTC)
When did the war happen
I have just gotten back into Dr. Who. Watched it as a kid on PBS and now that Scifi has it, I have gotten back in. In whatch many old episodes i saw the time lords still alive and have yet to figure out when the time war happened. Can any one tell me at least what Dr. fought in the war I know it had to be the 7th to 4th, but want to narrow it down.
- The Time War happens off screen at some point after the Doctor Who (1996) film with Doctor number 8 and Rose (TV story) at the start of the revived series with doc number 9 - it has not yet been shown on TV, just something that is reffered to. It's not entirely clear what happens in it as a result. Jack's the man - 23:57, 29 December 2008 (UTC)
Hello,
I must ask this question. Why does this article suggest the doctor implied he played a great part in the Time war(sourcing Dalek) then suddenly following up that he only suggested it because the Beast called him killer of his own kind(Satan Pit). These two episode are not related and did not even happen to the same doctor.
Doctor Who IX didn't imply a major role, he outright states he watched the ship burn, then stresses that he made them burn. This does not say implication to me.
Doctor Who X has built on that admission through implication, such as the Satan Pit, when the Beast calls him Killer of his own kind, the Doctor doesn't challenge him implying that he is right.
In essence, I think this article needs to be cleared up in that respect.
Also I don't know how cannon a comic book store is to the overall story of the Doctor. I have doubts about the peace treaty that allowed the Doctor to take the Master's remains from Skaro. If you watch the movie, you see that the Daleks judge the Master for all his evil crimes...almost as if they were acting as fair and impartial judges, strange when the Master has worked with them. I think some of the movie is confusing enough without mixing in questionable cannon of comic books. That, however, is mere opinion.
Tekphoenix 03:20, 31 December 2008 (UTC)FolaTekphoenix 03:20, 31 December 2008 (UTC)
the reason it is implied that the doctor says to the Dalek in van staterns lab in the episode dalek when talking about the end of the time war
'I watched it happen I made it Happen'
also in the sound of drums he tells the master that he ended the war and that the timelords and fro most part the daleks were dead
Watch the episodes Dalek , sound of drums and the episode satan pit that sohuold show you why it is implied.
As for the fair trial look at Romannas page i belive that explains it Assassin of death 13:57, 8 June 2009 (UTC) Assassin of death
Hi,
I have always believed that as the first mention of the actual time war seems to be in the 9th doctors series that either the 8th Doctor (Paul Mcgann) or the 9th Doctor took place in the time war, though I;'m not sure if the time or Doctor has actually been decided yet. That my view anyway, thanks for listening.
Where did the pic in this article come from?
It shows an explosion below and a bunch of saucers (Dalek ships, most likely) being swallowed up in the blast and exploding. Was this the Doctor sending an explosive to the surface of Gallifrey and blowing it up to kill the Daleks? I've never seen an actual flashback segment of the War on the tv series so where does this pic come from? Bttsstewart 01:31, 12 July 2009 (UTC)