Howling:RTD writing for eleventh doctor: Difference between revisions
Catkind121 (talk | contribs) No edit summary |
m (Robot: Automated text replacement (-{{Forumheader|The Howling}} +{{Archive|The Howling archives}})) |
||
| (2 intermediate revisions by 2 users not shown) | |||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
{{ | {{Archive|The Howling archives}}<!-- Please put your content under this line. Be sure to sign your edits with four tildes: ~~~~ --> | ||
I just read RTD is writing the episode of the sarah Jane adventures that the eleventh doctor and Jo Grant are in. How wierd is that even when he is away he is continuing to revive old icons in doctor who. So now that he has broken his "I am never going to write for the eleventh doctor thats steven and matts doctor" do you think he will break his never going to write for the parent series again. I must say I am looking forward to seeing how RTD will tackle the eleventh doctor. I wonder if he will write really well for him or if he will just kinda be like the tenth doctor played by Matt smith. Personally I never did believe that RTD would stick to his never writing for the parent series again, he is still commited to Torchwood which is from the looks of things more popular than ever, and sarah jane adventures, how can he possibly spearhead those two spin off's and not contribute any way to doctor who. | I just read RTD is writing the episode of the sarah Jane adventures that the eleventh doctor and Jo Grant are in. How wierd is that even when he is away he is continuing to revive old icons in doctor who. So now that he has broken his "I am never going to write for the eleventh doctor thats steven and matts doctor" do you think he will break his never going to write for the parent series again. I must say I am looking forward to seeing how RTD will tackle the eleventh doctor. I wonder if he will write really well for him or if he will just kinda be like the tenth doctor played by Matt smith. Personally I never did believe that RTD would stick to his never writing for the parent series again, he is still commited to Torchwood which is from the looks of things more popular than ever, and sarah jane adventures, how can he possibly spearhead those two spin off's and not contribute any way to doctor who. | ||
| Line 8: | Line 8: | ||
I for one believe that RTD had his time with Doctor Who: he had four seasons to do what he wanted and even if he made the revived series into a very popular one, I personally find his stories were often filled with promise but with very anti-climactic endings. The drive to make every series finale bigger and bigger is something that got started by RTD and is one of the things I personally dislike about the new series. RTD always ended up going over the top and often replacing logic and explanations with drama and emotional scenes. Again, good premises, but without anyone holding on to the reins he simply did not know when to quit. Who knows, maybe with Moffat doing the editing his stories could get the polish they need. --[[User:EltharionDrax|EltharionDrax]] 16:04, June 27, 2010 (UTC) | I for one believe that RTD had his time with Doctor Who: he had four seasons to do what he wanted and even if he made the revived series into a very popular one, I personally find his stories were often filled with promise but with very anti-climactic endings. The drive to make every series finale bigger and bigger is something that got started by RTD and is one of the things I personally dislike about the new series. RTD always ended up going over the top and often replacing logic and explanations with drama and emotional scenes. Again, good premises, but without anyone holding on to the reins he simply did not know when to quit. Who knows, maybe with Moffat doing the editing his stories could get the polish they need. --[[User:EltharionDrax|EltharionDrax]] 16:04, June 27, 2010 (UTC) | ||
Winehouse fan how could you not know that Jo Grant and the 11th Dr were going to be in the sarah jane adventures it has been news for months. --Catkind121 15:26, July 13, 2010 (UTC) | Winehouse fan how could you not know that Jo Grant and the 11th Dr were going to be in the sarah jane adventures it has been news for months. --Catkind121 15:26, July 13, 2010 | ||
(UTC) | |||
To be fair this post is old its been here for a while. I'm amazed its up here again I think someone chnaged something minor on it and thats why it was up her you know how that is when someone changes it woithout writing like say fixing a paragraph that may have gone wrong I appreciate that but I'm just saying it is relatively old though I am sometimes out of the loop like I haven't been able to download City of the Daleks yet the third one is almost out. Winehousefan, 16:55, July 13, 2010 [UTC] | |||
Latest revision as of 19:51, 7 November 2011
Please DO NOT add to this discussion.
I just read RTD is writing the episode of the sarah Jane adventures that the eleventh doctor and Jo Grant are in. How wierd is that even when he is away he is continuing to revive old icons in doctor who. So now that he has broken his "I am never going to write for the eleventh doctor thats steven and matts doctor" do you think he will break his never going to write for the parent series again. I must say I am looking forward to seeing how RTD will tackle the eleventh doctor. I wonder if he will write really well for him or if he will just kinda be like the tenth doctor played by Matt smith. Personally I never did believe that RTD would stick to his never writing for the parent series again, he is still commited to Torchwood which is from the looks of things more popular than ever, and sarah jane adventures, how can he possibly spearhead those two spin off's and not contribute any way to doctor who. Winehousefan, 12:40, June 13, 2010 [UTC]
I read that Moffat is desperate for RTD to return and write an episode of series six. Do you guys think he will do it and would you like to see RTD write for the eleventh doctor let me know what you think also guys I think that this should go on the rumours page on series six. Winehousefan. 11:00, June 27, 2010 [UTC]
I for one believe that RTD had his time with Doctor Who: he had four seasons to do what he wanted and even if he made the revived series into a very popular one, I personally find his stories were often filled with promise but with very anti-climactic endings. The drive to make every series finale bigger and bigger is something that got started by RTD and is one of the things I personally dislike about the new series. RTD always ended up going over the top and often replacing logic and explanations with drama and emotional scenes. Again, good premises, but without anyone holding on to the reins he simply did not know when to quit. Who knows, maybe with Moffat doing the editing his stories could get the polish they need. --EltharionDrax 16:04, June 27, 2010 (UTC)
Winehouse fan how could you not know that Jo Grant and the 11th Dr were going to be in the sarah jane adventures it has been news for months. --Catkind121 15:26, July 13, 2010
(UTC)
To be fair this post is old its been here for a while. I'm amazed its up here again I think someone chnaged something minor on it and thats why it was up her you know how that is when someone changes it woithout writing like say fixing a paragraph that may have gone wrong I appreciate that but I'm just saying it is relatively old though I am sometimes out of the loop like I haven't been able to download City of the Daleks yet the third one is almost out. Winehousefan, 16:55, July 13, 2010 [UTC]
