|
|
| (43 intermediate revisions by 11 users not shown) |
| Line 1: |
Line 1: |
| | | {{ArchCat}} |
| == Article needs renaming ==
| |
| | |
| It's been confirmed that the character will appear in a later episode, so the DAB nature of the title is inaccurate and will prevent users from finding the article on him, especially if the DAB page at [[Brian Williams]] is deleted by those who seem to want this wiki to be hard to navigate. [[Special:Contributions/70.72.211.35|70.72.211.35]]<sup>[[User talk:70.72.211.35#top|talk to me]]</sup> 02:40, September 9, 2012 (UTC)
| |
| :Disambiguation articles are there to navigate people to the correct article(s). When you search for something they're pretty much the first thing you see. Plus, on most articles it suggests pages that you might have meant when you loaded the article. I don't really think there's an issue tbh. Plus, the Brian Williams in the NSA "Snowglobe 7" came first and there's very little we can do about it.<br>
| |
| :[[User:Thefartydoctor|<font color="blue">The</font><font color="silver">Farty</font><font color="red">Doctor</font>]] [[User talk:Thefartydoctor|<small><sup><font color="green">Talk</font></sup></small>]] 03:02, September 9, 2012 (UTC)
| |
| | |
| ::The page still needs to be disambiguated, even if he appears in a later episode. As this is his first, this is what we go with. '''[[User:Tardis1963|<span style="background:#0E234E; color:white">Tardis1963</span>]]''' '''[[User talk:Tardis1963|<span style="background:#0E234E; color:white">talk</span>]]''' 03:41, September 9, 2012 (UTC)
| |
| | |
| :::For cases when there's only two people, {{tl|You may}} is more than enough to alleviate the confusion. Often, when you start typing Brian Williams in a link, it'd show the two dabed Brian Williamses. -- [[User:Tybort|Tybort]] ([[User talk:Tybort|talk page]]) 11:37, September 9, 2012 (UTC)
| |
| | |
| ::::It does seem that the Doctor's wife's Grandfather is going to remain more notable than a one off character in a novel. Perhaps Brian (Dinos on a Spaceship) should be the one listed as Brian Williams and a {{tl|You may}} link could handle the rest. The page for (Snowglobe 7) is barely a blip as it is, clearly Rory's dad is already more interesting.{{Unsigned|AnaxagorasZ}}
| |
| | |
| At a later date, when this character has made multiple appearances, it would certainly be best to give this page preference as I do not doubt it is the page most expect to find at [[Brian Williams]]. There is no urgency to make the move, but I see no reason to delay as links will only have to be changed when the switch is made and they're sure to pile up in the meantime.--{{User:Skittles the hog/sig}} 20:05, September 9, 2012 (UTC)
| |
| | |
| :When [[Amy Pond]] first appeared in [[The Eleventh Hour]], the page was named 'Amy Pond' not 'Amy Pond (The Eleventh Hour)'. So I completely agree that this page should be renamed. [[Special:Contributions/86.22.110.143|86.22.110.143]]<sup>[[User talk:86.22.110.143#top|talk to me]]</sup> 12:16, September 15, 2012 (UTC)
| |
| | |
| :: While I'm not completely opposed to the idea of ''maybe'' making this the "prime" Brian Williams page, the Amy argument has nothing to do with anything. amy has appeared [[Amy Pond - List of Appearances|in far more media than just one or two episodes]], including three comic series running at the same time. I don't know of any conflicting Amy Ponds like with [[Brian Williams (Snowglobe 7)]] (which until DOAS' airdate ''was'' the Brian Williams page), so for what purpose would we even ''consider'' requiring an Amy Pond page with the disambiguation term (The Eleventh Hour)? -- [[User:Tybort|Tybort]] ([[User talk:Tybort|talk page]]) 13:27, September 15, 2012 (UTC)
| |
| :::Conversely, I ''am'' totally opposed to dropping the dab term from the full article name. There's no cause to make an exception to policy in this case. He's not more important than the Snowglobe 7 guy, because core site policy sets all media as of equal weight. {{user:CzechOut/Sig}}{{User:CzechOut/TimeFormat}} 06:00: Mon 17 Sep 2012</span>
| |
| :::Moreover, it's an ''incredibly'' common name. I'm not entirely convinced there's not another Brian Williams somewhere in some story we've not got around to cataloguing yet. And given that we have two stories in 5 years to use the name Brian Williams, I certainly don't think it's unlikely that there will be another Brian Williams somewhere down the road. One thing people are forgetting in this thread is that we've only got about 30k articles on this wiki, and a lot of those are behind the scenes pages. We've barely begun to scratch the surface of in-universe characters. We use dab term naming as much to futureproof ourselves as to make differentiations that we're sure about. I can't see a situation whereby it'd be good policy to move this to Brian Williams; we're only gonna have to move it back. {{user:CzechOut/Sig}}{{User:CzechOut/TimeFormat}} 06:10: Mon 17 Sep 2012</span>
| |
| | |
| ==Leadworth==
| |
| Where is it established that he is from Leadworth? The only time he has been seen is at Amy and Rory's house (last we heard they are in London), and he was never mentioned, or seen during the adventures set in Leadworth. He is not even present at the wedding, which took place in Leadworth. [[User:Geek Mythology|Geek Mythology]] [[User talk:Geek Mythology|<span title="Talk to me">☎</span>]] 21:28, September 9, 2012 (UTC)
| |
| | |
| == Another victim of the silly Disambiguation policy on this wiki ==
| |
| There are a number of wiki users like myself who don't bother using the search tool and instead just browse to ''tardis.wikia.com/wiki/<search term>''. This is how I get to most pages, and finding that disambiguation pages have been deleted because there's only two or three similarly-named entries is, frankly, a bit rubbish, and makes the wiki very hard to navigate.
| |
| | |
| I'm strongly in favour of either renaming this article to simply [[Brian Williams]], or recreating the disambiguation page. Certainly the article's current title, which includes the name of what will be only the first appearance of the character, is not the way to go. [[User:Ben Paddon|Ben Paddon]] [[User talk:Ben Paddon|<span title="Talk to me">☎</span>]] 20:24, September 11, 2012 (UTC)
| |
| :Yes, our dab policy ''would'' look pretty stupid to someone who doesn't use the search tool. Obviously, though, using your browser's URL field '''isn't in any way a search'''. You should only use that method when you're sure of an article's name. There is absolutely no reasonable expectation that a name as common as "Brian Williams" would have appeared only once in a franchise that's 50 years old and comprised of thousands of unique stories.
| |
| | |
| :In calling our dab policy "stupid", you're not really understanding the challenges of organising information on a franchise that's 50 years old and comprised of thousands of stories. The DWU requires a different approach to naming that ''is'' dependant on using the search tool. If you used the search tool, you'd soon discover that it produces auto suggestions which then reveal the wisdom of the dab policy. Moreover, having the dab terms helps during editing, where autosuggestions are also prevalent. Without a consistent policy of applying the name of a character's first policy to their name, editing and searching would in fact be much more difficult. It's a good thing to have dab terms like we do, because it makes it completely obvious which Brian Williams you're looking for. {{user:CzechOut/Sig}}{{User:CzechOut/TimeFormat}} 05:45: Mon 17 Sep 2012</span>
| |
| | |
| == Spelling ==
| |
| | |
| Somebody, no idea who, but somebody sucks at spelling. This page was at the correct "Brian Williams (Dinosaurs on a Spaceship)", but somebody, no idea who, who I'd assume is not as good at English usage as they think they are, moved the correct page to an incorrect title. Can an admin please move it back to the correct title? Unless all of a sudden 'soar'ing is the new dinosaur roaring. '''[[User:Tardis1963|<span style="background:#0E234E; color:white">Tardis1963</span>]]''' '''[[User talk:Tardis1963|<span style="background:#0E234E; color:white">talk</span>]]''' 06:07, September 17, 2012 (UTC)
| |
| :It's a truism of, well, ''life'' that people make mistakes. Take it easy, big fella. {{user:CzechOut/Sig}}{{User:CzechOut/TimeFormat}} 06:32: Mon 17 Sep 2012</span>
| |
| | |
| ==I support the name change==
| |
| Just like to say I support the name change. I struggled to find this character, using google. It took me to the page [[Brian]]. Considering the number of Brians in Doctor Who i think that [[Brian]] should be made a disambiguation or at least have a (bracketed conxtext) in the page title.
| |
| | |
| The "Dinosaurs on a Spaceship" title is now irrelevant. Just had to share my thoughts.
| |
| | |
| -[[User:Thomaslove92|Thomas Love]] [http://jackass.wikia.com/wiki/User%3AThomaslove92 http://images1.wikia.nocookie.net/jackass/images/5/5f/Star_tiny.png] <small><nowiki>[</nowiki>[[User talk:Thomaslove92|talk]]<nowiki>]</nowiki></small> 13:48, October 12, 2012 (UTC)
| |
| | |
| * He's now appeared in ''[[Dinosaurs on a Spaceship]]'', ''[[The Power of Three]]'', and ''[[P.S. (webcast)|P.S.]]''. As the only other "Brian Williams" on record is a three-line page, I also support moving this to [[Brian Williams]]. If another particularly notable Brian Williams turns up, we can re-disambiguate this page as necessary. NOT doing it because there MAY be another B.W. somewhere down the line in either direction is frankly silly. '''<font color=#609000>d</font> [[User:Witoki|<font color=#609000>●</font>]][[User_talk:Witoki|<font color=#FF6090>•</font>]][[Special:Contributions/Witoki|<font color=#6090FF>·</font>]]''' 13:58, October 12, 2012 (UTC)
| |
| | |
| *Yeah, man, this is absurd. Rory's dad is obviously the most notable Brian Williams. He's not just the Brian Williams from ''Dinosaurs on a Spaceship'', he's a prominent reoccurring character. Parenthetically noting the story a character was in works when the character was only in one story, but in cases where a character was in multiple stories it looks like an error, and is certainly more confusing than useful for casual users. Any wiki policy that demands that article names be formatted in this way has to change if the wiki isn't going to look like a parody of itself. -- [[User:Rowan Earthwood|Rowan Earthwood]] [[User talk:Rowan Earthwood|<span title="Talk to me">☎</span>]] 01:12, October 16, 2012 (UTC)
| |
| | |
| ::I think you guys don't understand our dismag policy... [[User:OttselSpy25|OS25]] ([[User Talk:OttselSpy25|talk to me, baby.]]) 17:32, October 19, 2012 (UTC)
| |
| :::Under the DAB policy header "Primary Topics":
| |
| ::::"Although a term may potentially refer to more than one topic, it sometimes is the case that '''one of these topics is far more likely to be the one a reader is searching for when searching in the Search box'''. If there is such a topic, then it is known as the primary topic for that term. If a primary topic exists, '''that article should be titled with no disambiguation''', however, with a note at the top of the article directing to a disambiguation page."
| |
| :::The likelihood that anyone is searching for [[Brian Williams (Snowglobe 7)]] is nearly zero, whereas searching for [[Brian Williams (Dinosaurs on a Spaceship)]], twice a companion with an entire webcast revolving around him, is substantially higher. It's like saying if there was a character named Craig Owens in [[Planet of the Spiders (TV story)]], who appeared in the first two minutes and was unceremoniously killed and never mentioned again, that the current Craig Owens would have to be "Craig Owens (The Lodger)" forever, despite being a direct companion twice, and the focus of both episodes. At WORST, Brian Williams should be "Brian Williams (companion)". '''<font color=#609000>d</font> [[User:Witoki|<font color=#609000>●</font>]][[User_talk:Witoki|<font color=#FF6090>•</font>]][[Special:Contributions/Witoki|<font color=#6090FF>·</font>]]''' 17:51, October 19, 2012 (UTC)
| |
| | |
| It looks like you skipped two important points to get to "Primary Topics". Take a look at [[Tardis:Disambiguation policy#Main Principles]] and [[Tardis:Disambiguation policy#Finer Detail]] and you'll see the more specific guidelines. I understand that at present Rory's dad is "far more likely to be the one a reader is searching for" but how long will that last? He's pretty important now, but in the long run he's just a minor character who appeared in a handful of episodes in half a series. We're not naming articles for the current series, but rather for the entire almost-50 year run of the show and its various media. [[User:Shambala108|Shambala108]] [[User talk:Shambala108|<span title="Talk to me">☎</span>]] 18:15, October 19, 2012 (UTC)
| |
