229,659
edits
User:SOTO/Forum Archive/The Panopticon/@comment-1046-20180501024620 (edit)
Revision as of 19:58, 27 April 2023
, 27 April 2023Bot: Automated text replacement (-'''User:(SOTO/Forum Archive)/(.*?)/\@comment-([\d\.]+)-(\d+)'''\n([\s\S]*)\[\[Category:SOTO archive posts\]\] +\5\2/\4-\3, -'''User:(SOTO/Forum Archive)/(.*?)/\@comment-(.*?)'''([\s\S]*) ?\{\{retitle\|///(.*?)\}\} +{{retitle|\2/\5}}\n'''User:\1/\2/@comment-\3'''\4)
(Bot: Automated import of articles) |
m (Bot: Automated text replacement (-'''User:(SOTO/Forum Archive)/(.*?)/\@comment-([\d\.]+)-(\d+)'''\n([\s\S]*)\[\[Category:SOTO archive posts\]\] +\5/-, -'''User:(SOTO/Forum Archive)/(.*?)/\@comment-(.*?)'''([\s\S]*) ?\{\{retitle\|///(.*?)\}\} +{{retitle|\2/\5}}\n'''User:\1/\2/@comment-\3'''\4)) |
||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
{{retitle|The Panopticon/Novelisation clarification}} | |||
[[Thread:231243]] ended with a decision that information from novelisations may be included in articles, but that when a novelisation gives a more complete name for a person than the televised story, the article name should be based on the TV version alone, as at [[Miranda (Doctor Who)]]. That's fine. But what about the cases in which a person's name is not given at all on TV, but the novelisation gives them a name? We have a short article at [[Mickey Smith's mother]]. [[Rose (novelisation)]] names her as Odessa Smith (and incidentally confirms that "couldn't cope" is a euphemism for her suicide). I would be inclined to move [[Mickey Smith's mother]] to [[Odessa Smith]], but the policy as written would seem to argue against that. Can we distinguish between cases in which a novelisation gives a surname to a character who doesn't have one on TV, and cases in which a novelisation gives a name to a character who doesn't have one at all on TV? | [[Thread:231243]] ended with a decision that information from novelisations may be included in articles, but that when a novelisation gives a more complete name for a person than the televised story, the article name should be based on the TV version alone, as at [[Miranda (Doctor Who)]]. That's fine. But what about the cases in which a person's name is not given at all on TV, but the novelisation gives them a name? We have a short article at [[Mickey Smith's mother]]. [[Rose (novelisation)]] names her as Odessa Smith (and incidentally confirms that "couldn't cope" is a euphemism for her suicide). I would be inclined to move [[Mickey Smith's mother]] to [[Odessa Smith]], but the policy as written would seem to argue against that. Can we distinguish between cases in which a novelisation gives a surname to a character who doesn't have one on TV, and cases in which a novelisation gives a name to a character who doesn't have one at all on TV? | ||
[[User:CzechOut|CzechOut]] explained the decision to use [[Miranda (Doctor Who)]] instead of [[Miranda Gerhardt]] as being in the interest of aiding casual readers of the site. But are casual readers more aided by an article titled [[Mickey Smith's mother]] than by one titled [[Odessa Smith]]? Surely the most likely method for anyone searching for an article on Mickey's mother would be for them to go to [[Mickey Smith]] and click on a link to the article on his mother, either in the infobox or in the article text. I could be wrong, but I don't think most readers would type "mickey smith's mother" in the search field. | [[User:CzechOut|CzechOut]] explained the decision to use [[Miranda (Doctor Who)]] instead of [[Miranda Gerhardt]] as being in the interest of aiding casual readers of the site. But are casual readers more aided by an article titled [[Mickey Smith's mother]] than by one titled [[Odessa Smith]]? Surely the most likely method for anyone searching for an article on Mickey's mother would be for them to go to [[Mickey Smith]] and click on a link to the article on his mother, either in the infobox or in the article text. I could be wrong, but I don't think most readers would type "mickey smith's mother" in the search field. | ||
<noinclude>[[Category:SOTO archive posts]]</noinclude> | <noinclude>[[Category:SOTO archive posts|The Panopticon/20180501024620-1046]]</noinclude> | ||