Talk:Dalek (TV story): Difference between revisions
(Don't make stuff up!) |
(→2.2 Updated with new information: new section) |
||
| (One intermediate revision by one other user not shown) | |||
| Line 2: | Line 2: | ||
==Don't make stuff up!== | ==Don't make stuff up!== | ||
Give me one line of dialogue from [[The Big Bang]] that says the events of this or any episode did not happen. You won't find one. Until and unless a future episode of Doctor Who includes a character stating "oh, yeah, everything changed and has been reset" then to say anything of this sort is | Give me one line of dialogue from [[The Big Bang]] that says the events of this or any episode did not happen. You won't find one. Until and unless a future episode of Doctor Who includes a character stating "oh, yeah, everything changed and has been reset" then to say anything of this sort is speculation and fanon of the worst kind. I deleted this nonsense, but kept the comment regarding Brooke because that is a viable example of on-screen evidence that actually supports the theory. One more comment: The Doctor states in The Big Bang that the univese has been "rebooted". In any definition of the term, reboot does NOT mean start from scratch, otherwise the "reboot" of Torchwood in 2011 would not be part of continuity, and everytime we "reboot" our computers, we'd lose all our data. Rebooting does not erase anything. [[Special:Contributions/68.146.81.123|68.146.81.123]] 22:37, August 11, 2010 (UTC) | ||
== 2.2 Updated with new information == | |||
== Placement of Explainable Errors == | |||
Can anyone advise on the best place for errors in an episode that can be explained - the talk page or within the entry? I only ask because I have a couple for this episode: | |||
*The map of the US shown on Van Statten's monitor is missing the upper peninsula of Michigan. | |||
**This could be missing in this version of 2012. | |||
*The security guard holding the stairs against the Dalek as Rose and Adam escape is given a close up as she's firing her gun. With every shot, she blinks, showing that the actress has had very little experience in firing firearms. | |||
**This can be explained by the fact that the guard in question has probably never needed to draw her weapon before, much less fire it! | |||
Latest revision as of 17:14, 30 August 2019
sorry about the page move - realised after i had done it but couldn't seem to change it back :/ Lord Aro 18:17, April 25, 2010 (UTC)
Don't make stuff up![[edit source]]
Give me one line of dialogue from The Big Bang that says the events of this or any episode did not happen. You won't find one. Until and unless a future episode of Doctor Who includes a character stating "oh, yeah, everything changed and has been reset" then to say anything of this sort is speculation and fanon of the worst kind. I deleted this nonsense, but kept the comment regarding Brooke because that is a viable example of on-screen evidence that actually supports the theory. One more comment: The Doctor states in The Big Bang that the univese has been "rebooted". In any definition of the term, reboot does NOT mean start from scratch, otherwise the "reboot" of Torchwood in 2011 would not be part of continuity, and everytime we "reboot" our computers, we'd lose all our data. Rebooting does not erase anything. 68.146.81.123 22:37, August 11, 2010 (UTC)
2.2 Updated with new information[[edit source]]
Placement of Explainable Errors[[edit source]]
Can anyone advise on the best place for errors in an episode that can be explained - the talk page or within the entry? I only ask because I have a couple for this episode:
- The map of the US shown on Van Statten's monitor is missing the upper peninsula of Michigan.
- This could be missing in this version of 2012.
- The security guard holding the stairs against the Dalek as Rose and Adam escape is given a close up as she's firing her gun. With every shot, she blinks, showing that the actress has had very little experience in firing firearms.
- This can be explained by the fact that the guard in question has probably never needed to draw her weapon before, much less fire it!
