Template talk:Cyberman stories: Difference between revisions
From Tardis Wiki, the free Doctor Who reference
No edit summary |
(→Story organisation: new section) Tag: 2017 source edit |
||
Line 9: | Line 9: | ||
The list is uneditable but there is a story missing: Junkyard Demon. Someone needs to add this. | The list is uneditable but there is a story missing: Junkyard Demon. Someone needs to add this. | ||
== Story organisation == | |||
Several things I want to point out: | |||
* For some reason, amongst the TV appearances, ''Once, Upon Time'' is listed as ''Flux: Once, Upon Time - Bel's Story'', a name which has never been used to refer to this story. Why ''Once, Upon Time'' isn't simply used instead is baffling to me. | |||
* I think that ''A Good Man Goes to War'' should also be added, as the Cybermen's appearance, although very small, is still particularly relevant to its plot, as Rory and the Eleventh Doctor confront the Cybermen to ascertain the location of Demons' Run, the main setting of the story. | |||
* Although they only appear very briefly in it, should we include ''The Vanquishers''? The Cybermen are an important part of the plot along with the Daleks. | |||
* Although I still need to read it, ''Loving the Alien'' contains lots of partially cyberconverted lifeforms (mainly humans and gorillas) and therefore should be placed between ''Vrs'' and ''Going Off the Rails''. | |||
* ''Status Update'' should be renamed to ''Cybermen: Status Update''. | |||
* Some of the audio stories are out of order, being listed after numerous stories when they actually released earlier. | |||
** ''Silver Lining'' should be after ''The Harvest'', then ''The Crystal of Cantus'' (which should probably be formatted with its full name), then ''The Reaping'', ''The Gathering'', then ''The Blue Tooth'', then ''Human Resources''. | |||
** ''The Isos Network'' should be between ''Return to Telos'' and ''The Tyrants of Logic''. | |||
* ''Keepsake'' should probably be included between ''Kingdom of Silver'' and ''Legend of the Cybermen'' due to featuring a Cybrid that serves as a key part of the plot, even if he's only in one scene. | |||
* Similarly to ''Loving the Alien'', ''Warzone'' should also be included between ''Hour of the Cybermen'' and ''Conversion'' as it includes people who are technically partially converted Cybermen, just to a more limited degree. | |||
* ''Prologue: The Third Doctor'' should be included with the other ''Supremacy of the Cybermen'' prologues as it features a partially converted Master. [[User:Thalek Prime Overseer|Thalek Prime Overseer]] [[User talk:Thalek Prime Overseer|<span title="Talk to me">☎</span>]] 15:03, 17 February 2022 (UTC) |
Revision as of 15:03, 17 February 2022
Suggestions
- Separate sections for Doctor Who and Torchwood (only one of the latter so far).
- Separate sections for the Mondasian Cybermen and Cybermen created by Cybus Industries.
- Maybe, There should definiatly be separate section (though inside the same box) between the Cybus and Mondasian, but I don't think it should be broken by which TV story series it's from as it's all part of the same chronology. It also should have 'Cybermen TV stories' (unless it's going to include all the NA/MA/PDA/BFA...etc stories). --Tangerineduel 15:22, 18 April 2008 (UTC)
Colour
As has been discussed with the season templates i think we need something a bit more than just two shades of Grey. Dark Lord Xander 11:10, 20 July 2008 (UTC)
The list is uneditable but there is a story missing: Junkyard Demon. Someone needs to add this.
Story organisation
Several things I want to point out:
- For some reason, amongst the TV appearances, Once, Upon Time is listed as Flux: Once, Upon Time - Bel's Story, a name which has never been used to refer to this story. Why Once, Upon Time isn't simply used instead is baffling to me.
- I think that A Good Man Goes to War should also be added, as the Cybermen's appearance, although very small, is still particularly relevant to its plot, as Rory and the Eleventh Doctor confront the Cybermen to ascertain the location of Demons' Run, the main setting of the story.
- Although they only appear very briefly in it, should we include The Vanquishers? The Cybermen are an important part of the plot along with the Daleks.
- Although I still need to read it, Loving the Alien contains lots of partially cyberconverted lifeforms (mainly humans and gorillas) and therefore should be placed between Vrs and Going Off the Rails.
- Status Update should be renamed to Cybermen: Status Update.
- Some of the audio stories are out of order, being listed after numerous stories when they actually released earlier.
- Silver Lining should be after The Harvest, then The Crystal of Cantus (which should probably be formatted with its full name), then The Reaping, The Gathering, then The Blue Tooth, then Human Resources.
- The Isos Network should be between Return to Telos and The Tyrants of Logic.
- Keepsake should probably be included between Kingdom of Silver and Legend of the Cybermen due to featuring a Cybrid that serves as a key part of the plot, even if he's only in one scene.
- Similarly to Loving the Alien, Warzone should also be included between Hour of the Cybermen and Conversion as it includes people who are technically partially converted Cybermen, just to a more limited degree.
- Prologue: The Third Doctor should be included with the other Supremacy of the Cybermen prologues as it features a partially converted Master. Thalek Prime Overseer ☎ 15:03, 17 February 2022 (UTC)