Talk:War Doctor/Archive 2: Difference between revisions

From Tardis Wiki, the free Doctor Who reference
No edit summary
Line 12: Line 12:


I think the name of this Doctor is a bit vague.  The Eleventh Doctor refers to this one as his secret.  I think referring to him as "the Secret Doctor" is a more apt description than "Unknown Doctor", "Unknown Iteration" or "The Doctor (The Name of the Doctor)".  I figure this is better from a narrative point of view for the wiki until we get a more apt description from the show.
I think the name of this Doctor is a bit vague.  The Eleventh Doctor refers to this one as his secret.  I think referring to him as "the Secret Doctor" is a more apt description than "Unknown Doctor", "Unknown Iteration" or "The Doctor (The Name of the Doctor)".  I figure this is better from a narrative point of view for the wiki until we get a more apt description from the show.
:I don't agree. He is credited as "The Doctor" in "The Name of the Doctor" so I believe it is a correct title for now for the article. When the Anniversary comes out I'm sure it will be changed but for now I think the current title is correct. --[[User:BorgKnight|BorgKnight]] [[User talk:BorgKnight|<span title="Talk to me">☎</span>]] 04:34, May 19, 2013 (UTC)

Revision as of 04:34, 19 May 2013

My theory

I know this is speculation. But instead of being an "8.5" or the "Real 9th Doctor", I reckon John Hurt will be playing an older Eighth Doctor. In the flashbacks, there was no Eighth Doctor, in the time stream sequence at the end when they were running past, there was no Eighth Doctor.

This way, none of the regenerations get messed around and from a story perspective it can still make perfect sense, not to mention, the costuming is a mix between 8 and 9. So that's my theory, John Hurt is playing an older 8th Doctor.

That is actually make pretty much sense... But Paul McGann and John Hurt are not similar in any way. Besides, we can actually see Eight running in the intro part (before the opening music), running just after the second Doctor. We can't see his face, but this is definitly the eight's Doctor's suit. Puchplimmirdeyslithin 23:38, May 18, 2013 (UTC)

This talk page is for discussing improvements to this article only. The place for theorising is Howling:The_Howling. — Rob T Firefly - Δ - 23:58, May 18, 2013 (UTC)

Article title

I think the name of this Doctor is a bit vague. The Eleventh Doctor refers to this one as his secret. I think referring to him as "the Secret Doctor" is a more apt description than "Unknown Doctor", "Unknown Iteration" or "The Doctor (The Name of the Doctor)". I figure this is better from a narrative point of view for the wiki until we get a more apt description from the show.

I don't agree. He is credited as "The Doctor" in "The Name of the Doctor" so I believe it is a correct title for now for the article. When the Anniversary comes out I'm sure it will be changed but for now I think the current title is correct. --BorgKnight 04:34, May 19, 2013 (UTC)