Talk:Lily (short story): Difference between revisions
From Tardis Wiki, the free Doctor Who reference
(→Lauren cannot exist in TV continuity: new section) Tag: sourceedit |
No edit summary Tag: sourceedit |
||
| Line 2: | Line 2: | ||
"Earlier in her personal timeline, she had met his tenth (TV: School Reunion) and eleventh incarnations (TV: Death of the Doctor)." - this doesn't work. In The Sarah Jane Adventures, Sarah was clearly childless until she adopted Luke and Sky. Considering that she would be over 60 by this point, it's simply not possible for her to meet 10 and 11 as seen in SJA, in the same timeline as this short story. If Lauren was born after the end of SJA, then Sarah would have to be around 90 when this story takes place. I think this story must've been retconned out, the same way Ace's comics death was. {{User:Digifiend/SigReal|21:51, 17/4/2015}} | "Earlier in her personal timeline, she had met his tenth (TV: School Reunion) and eleventh incarnations (TV: Death of the Doctor)." - this doesn't work. In The Sarah Jane Adventures, Sarah was clearly childless until she adopted Luke and Sky. Considering that she would be over 60 by this point, it's simply not possible for her to meet 10 and 11 as seen in SJA, in the same timeline as this short story. If Lauren was born after the end of SJA, then Sarah would have to be around 90 when this story takes place. I think this story must've been retconned out, the same way Ace's comics death was. {{User:Digifiend/SigReal|21:51, 17/4/2015}} | ||
:Neither you nor SJA has the power to "retcon" things with contradictions. SJA and this story are equally valid sources. | |||
Revision as of 15:06, 15 January 2016
Lauren cannot exist in TV continuity
"Earlier in her personal timeline, she had met his tenth (TV: School Reunion) and eleventh incarnations (TV: Death of the Doctor)." - this doesn't work. In The Sarah Jane Adventures, Sarah was clearly childless until she adopted Luke and Sky. Considering that she would be over 60 by this point, it's simply not possible for her to meet 10 and 11 as seen in SJA, in the same timeline as this short story. If Lauren was born after the end of SJA, then Sarah would have to be around 90 when this story takes place. I think this story must've been retconned out, the same way Ace's comics death was. Digifiend Talk PR/SS KR MH Toku JD Garo TH CG UM Logos CLG DW 21:51, 17/4/2015
- Neither you nor SJA has the power to "retcon" things with contradictions. SJA and this story are equally valid sources.
