Template talk:Companions of the Seventh Doctor: Difference between revisions
No edit summary |
No edit summary |
||
| Line 41: | Line 41: | ||
==Why is Mags listed as original to audio?== | ==Why is Mags listed as original to audio?== | ||
She is original to TV. She became a companion on audio but yet she is original to TV. On a similar note, Grace from the TV Movie is listed as original to TV in the companion template for the 8th Doctor, but she only became a companion in the comics. We need it to be standardized. [[User:DenisLuiz|DenisLuiz]] [[User talk:DenisLuiz|<span title="Talk to me">☎</span>]] 02:44, February 1, 2020 (UTC) | She is original to TV. She became a companion on audio but yet she is original to TV. On a similar note, Grace from the TV Movie is listed as original to TV in the companion template for the 8th Doctor, but she only became a companion in the comics. We need it to be standardized. [[User:DenisLuiz|DenisLuiz]] [[User talk:DenisLuiz|<span title="Talk to me">☎</span>]] 02:44, February 1, 2020 (UTC) | ||
== Proposed update == | |||
{{Navbox | |||
|bodyclass = glow | |||
|name = Companions of the Seventh Doctor | |||
|title = Companions of the [[Seventh Doctor]] | |||
|titleclass = | |||
|imageleft = HartnellHeadOn.jpg | |||
|above = | |||
|state = collapsed | |||
|group1 = Television | |||
|list1 = | |||
{{Navbox|child | |||
|group1 = Traveling | |||
|list1 = [[Melanie Bush]] • [[Ace]] | |||
|group2 = Single-adventure | |||
|list2 = | |||
|group3 = Occasional adventures | |||
|list3 = | |||
|group4 = Narratively ambiguous | |||
|list4 = | |||
}} | |||
|group2 = Prose | |||
|list2 = | |||
{{Navbox|child | |||
|group1 = Traveling | |||
|list1 = [[Melanie Bush]] • [[Ace]] • [[Bernice Summerfield]] • [[Wolsey]] • [[Roz Forrester]] • [[Chris Cwej]] • [[Neil Hilton]] • [[Hex]] • [[Tramp (The Tramp's Story)|The Tramp]] • [[Catherine Broome]] | |||
|group2 = Single-adventure | |||
|list2 = [[Sarah Jane Smith]] | |||
|group3 = Occasional adventures | |||
|list3 = | |||
|group4 = Narratively ambiguous | |||
|list4 = [[Ruby Duvall]] • [[Private (Front Line)|Private]] | |||
}} | |||
|group3 = Comics | |||
|list3 = | |||
{{Navbox|child | |||
|group1 = Traveling | |||
|list1 = [[Melanie Bush]] • [[Ace]] • [[Olla]] • [[Bernice Summerfield]] | |||
|group2 = Single-adventure | |||
|list2 = [[Mags (The Greatest Show in the Galaxy)|Mags]] • [[Frobisher]] • [[Leapy]] • [[Abslom Daak]] • [[Ly-Chee]] • [[Sarah Jane Smith]] | |||
|group3 = Occasional adventures | |||
|list3 = | |||
|group4 = Narratively ambiguous | |||
|list4 = | |||
}} | |||
|group4 = Audio | |||
|list4 = | |||
{{Navbox|child | |||
|group1 = Traveling | |||
|list1 = [[Melanie Bush]] • [[Ace]] • [[Bernice Summerfield]] • [[Roz Forrester]] • [[Chris Cwej]] • [[Bev Tarrant]] • [[Hex]] • [[Sally Morgan]] • [[Lysandra Aristedes]] • [[Mags (The Greatest Show in the Galaxy)|Mags]] • [[Elizabeth Klein]] • [[Will Arrowsmith]] | |||
|group2 = Single-adventure | |||
|list2 = [[Jo Grant]] • [[Mike Yates]] • [[Zanzibar Hashtag]] • [[Liv Chenka]] • [[Rachel Cooper]] • [[Jemima (The Two Masters)|Jemima]] | |||
|group3 = Occasional adventures | |||
|list3 = [[Raine Creevy]] | |||
|group4 = Narratively ambiguous | |||
|list4 = | |||
}} | |||
}} | |||
Revision as of 15:19, 26 May 2020
Ly-Chee
Anybody know who this character is? Please respond at Forum:Ly-Chee.
czechout<staff /> ☎ ✍ 03:56:16 Mon 13 Jun 2011
New image
Since the previous image was deleted, I propose this as a replacement. Memnarc talk to me 05:10, June 1, 2012 (UTC)
Lysandra Aristedes
When Black And White is released we need to add Lysandra Aristedes to the original to audio section of this page, as it said in official Big Finish news thar she is a companion. AdricLovesNyssa Saturday 11:08:2012 11:22 UTC
Although she is now in the category of Seventh Doctor Companions, she still hasn't been added to this list. Someone with permission needs to get on that. 219.90.215.174talk to me 03:05, August 18, 2012 (UTC)
Update
There are a few companions missing from this template:
- Audio: Rachel Cooper (multi-adventure)
- Prose: Jason Kane (multi-story), Ruby Duvall (single adventure)
- Comics: Sarah Jane Smith (single adventure)
Also, Prose can probably be broken up into single adventure, multi-adventure, and multi-story. P&P talk contribs 19:36, September 21, 2014 (UTC)
Brigadier
Can we include the Brigadier in this, in the television section? – The preceding unsigned comment was added by Fireball99 (talk • contribs) .
Mags and the Private
Mags needs to be added at some stage, though I imagine that’s just down to someone finding a moment to add her. Not sure whether she should be TV original or audio original though.
I also think the Private should be removed entirely from the list. I understand the reasons for including characters such as Ruby Duvall and Jemima due to the fact that they were both offered the chance to become companions and accepted, but didn’t stay long for different reasons.
This Private character however appeared in one short story that amounted to nothing more than a conversation between himself and the Doctor. There’s no alien to fight or adventure to be had, they simply spoke about War. The Doctor did offer him companionship - that much is true. However he flatly turned the Doctor down, who promptly went on his way.
I’d argue that he just doesn’t fit the criteria to be listed as a companion.
SarahJaneFan ☎ 14:21, April 17, 2019 (UTC)
Why is Mags listed as original to audio?
She is original to TV. She became a companion on audio but yet she is original to TV. On a similar note, Grace from the TV Movie is listed as original to TV in the companion template for the 8th Doctor, but she only became a companion in the comics. We need it to be standardized. DenisLuiz ☎ 02:44, February 1, 2020 (UTC)
Proposed update
| |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
