User talk:Emily Solt

Self wikifying

Hi if you are the Russell McGee that has a page on this wiki, please note that Tardis:Valid sources states that authors, actors and other crew may not edit pages about themselves or their works. In addition, please note that Tardis:Username policy forbids the use of "sockpuppets".

We also have a rule against plagiarism; see Tardis:Plagiarism. Thanks Shambala108 ☎ 18:27, 12 September 2022 (UTC)

Re the recent edit on Russell McGee: You certainly haven't been following the rules up until now, and technically speaking, since you aren't Krohn, you're arguably still committing plagiarism, per T:DON'T COPY. But this looks on the surface like a reasonable edit, modulo concerns about conflicts of interest and overly florid prose. Najawin ☎ 06:37, 13 September 2022 (UTC)

Briefly adding my two cents in this: please, in the futre, add original content rather than "adapting from outside sources", however much you adapt it. As a Wiki, we mostly prefer to have original content. That said, I do have a small issue with the current setup of Russell McGee: beyond the (very briefs) two first paragraphs, the page turns from "DWU-related biography of the individual" into "extremely detailed biography of this person's career and background".

But we're not Wikipedia, where all of that information would be surely suited. We, as a Doctor Who (and it's spin-offs) Wiki, are only in need of whatever is related to McGee's DWU career. Notice how even on high-profile pages like Russell T Davies and Steven Moffat we don't deviate too much to their career previous and post-Who. But anyway, that's more a concern for a {{cleanup}} template on that page. OncomingStorm12th ☎ 19:32, 16 September 2022 (UTC)

Hello, OncomingStorm12th and Shambala108

RussellMcGee77 asked me to update the wiki entry after Najawin made the initial reversions to the wiki. Russell explained to me that in the past, he had been able to update the wiki entry on this site. The rules changed and in response to Najawin Russell followed the new rules and asked another user, myself, to revise the wiki on his behalf.

(https://tardis.fandom.com/wiki/Tardis:Don%27t_wikify_your_own_material) "...seek out other editors and inform them of the edit you wish performed..."

I also asked Nick Krohn, a long writing friend of Russell's as I am not a writer, to draft a new version of Russell's bio so that Najawin could not claim plagiarism.

I am also not sure why Russell's date of birth keeps being removed from the wiki, when Russell's birth is a public record and freely available through IMDB.

Additionally, the headshot that was taken of Russell holding the Temporal Logbook II (A Doctor Who Anthology Charity Publication) keeps being removed, which was used as part of the publicity for SARAH JANE SMITH: ROVING REPORTER. The headshot has also been used in multiple online sites including THE BRANDON PETERS SHOW (https://thebrandonpetersshow.com/episode/daleks-invasion-earth-2150-a-d-with-russell-mcgee/) and on the National Audio Theater Festivals: (https://www.natf.org/about/).

I'd appreciate it and Russell would appreciate it, if someone were able to re-post his headshot and add his date of birth as part of the biographical information.

I hope this helps, we are not trying to create issues for you and are trying to follow the revised rules for the site.

Best

Emily