User:SOTO/Forum Archive/The Panopticon/@comment-1296654-20200616211544/@comment-6032121-20200616230807: Difference between revisions
(Bot: Automated import of articles) |
m (Bot: Automated text replacement (-'''User:(SOTO/Forum Archive)/(.*?)/\@comment-([\d\.]+)-(\d+)/\@comment-([\d\.]+)-(\d+)'''\n([\s\S]*)\[\[Category:SOTO archive posts\]\] +\7\2/\4-\3/\6-\5)) |
||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
I don't know, is there any interesting precedent on this? I feel like if we were told that (say) [[Amy Pond]], daughter of [[Augustus Pond]] and [[Tabetha Pond]] had an offscreen older brother called Preston, we wouldn't actually need a confirmation of the full name to put it at [[Preston Pond]] rather than [[Preston (Doctor Who and the Thought Experiment)]]. I could be wrong. If a case like my thought experiment could be found, presumably not about as high-profile a character as Amy, that'd be grand, but I have no idea how to even start searching. | I don't know, is there any interesting precedent on this? I feel like if we were told that (say) [[Amy Pond]], daughter of [[Augustus Pond]] and [[Tabetha Pond]] had an offscreen older brother called Preston, we wouldn't actually need a confirmation of the full name to put it at [[Preston Pond]] rather than [[Preston (Doctor Who and the Thought Experiment)]]. I could be wrong. If a case like my thought experiment could be found, presumably not about as high-profile a character as Amy, that'd be grand, but I have no idea how to even start searching. | ||
(I don't actually think the comparison to 'dancing' in ''[[The Doctor Dances (TV story)|The Doctor Dances]]'' is as apt as all that. I mean yes, it's an example of us exercising some common sense about stuff that is never ''voiced'' in so many words, but made explicit on other ways. But it's quite a different situation. If nothing else, that issue has nothing to do with page naming, even though that is its own set of conventions separate from what is speculation; it's not speculation that [[Bruce (Doctor Who)|the guy from the ambulance]] was called 'Bruce Gerhardt', but it's still not good enough for it to be the page name.) | (I don't actually think the comparison to 'dancing' in ''[[The Doctor Dances (TV story)|The Doctor Dances]]'' is as apt as all that. I mean yes, it's an example of us exercising some common sense about stuff that is never ''voiced'' in so many words, but made explicit on other ways. But it's quite a different situation. If nothing else, that issue has nothing to do with page naming, even though that is its own set of conventions separate from what is speculation; it's not speculation that [[Bruce (Doctor Who)|the guy from the ambulance]] was called 'Bruce Gerhardt', but it's still not good enough for it to be the page name.) | ||
<noinclude>[[Category:SOTO archive posts]]</noinclude> | <noinclude>[[Category:SOTO archive posts|The Panopticon/20200616211544-1296654/20200616230807-6032121]]</noinclude> | ||
Latest revision as of 20:42, 27 April 2023
I don't know, is there any interesting precedent on this? I feel like if we were told that (say) Amy Pond, daughter of Augustus Pond and Tabetha Pond had an offscreen older brother called Preston, we wouldn't actually need a confirmation of the full name to put it at Preston Pond rather than Preston (Doctor Who and the Thought Experiment). I could be wrong. If a case like my thought experiment could be found, presumably not about as high-profile a character as Amy, that'd be grand, but I have no idea how to even start searching.
(I don't actually think the comparison to 'dancing' in The Doctor Dances is as apt as all that. I mean yes, it's an example of us exercising some common sense about stuff that is never voiced in so many words, but made explicit on other ways. But it's quite a different situation. If nothing else, that issue has nothing to do with page naming, even though that is its own set of conventions separate from what is speculation; it's not speculation that the guy from the ambulance was called 'Bruce Gerhardt', but it's still not good enough for it to be the page name.)
