68,220
edits
More actions
reply
mNo edit summary |
(reply) |
||
| Line 25: | Line 25: | ||
:Okay, I've created a mock-up possible DVD article on ''[[Genesis of the Daleks]]''. To avoid messing up any existing articles, I made it in my user page at [[User:David the Wavid]]. Obviously it doesn't contain an infobox as one hasn't been created for DVDs but I did what I could. Any further comments or should I scrap it? [[User:David the Wavid|David]] 21:36, 27 October 2007 (UTC) | :Okay, I've created a mock-up possible DVD article on ''[[Genesis of the Daleks]]''. To avoid messing up any existing articles, I made it in my user page at [[User:David the Wavid]]. Obviously it doesn't contain an infobox as one hasn't been created for DVDs but I did what I could. Any further comments or should I scrap it? [[User:David the Wavid|David]] 21:36, 27 October 2007 (UTC) | ||
::Well I'm relatively convinced, though the one suggestion I would make is that the article contains the information for all releases of said story (ie VHS/Laserdisc (should it be one of the stories to have been)/DVD). | |||
::Unless there should be individual articles for all of the various formats? That's the only thing I've been wondering about, as the DVDs can easily fill a page on their own, but could the VHS? Some of them got multiple/re-releases so there probably could be enough information to make an article for them. | |||
::But to answer your above questions (after now added my own to ponder on) I think all the ''stories'' should have DVD articles, except the new series releases which should be dealt with as the big season boxed sets (with a heading in the page dealing with the 'Vanilla' releases perhaps). Actually any classic series stories released as a boxed set would also have their own page (in addition to the individual boxed sets in the case of the Davros set etc), so in that case you'd have links off to the DVD pages. So something like the New Beginnings set would have the 3 separate pages for Keeper of Traken, Logopolis and Castrovalva, but also a 'New Beginnings' DVD set, which would have links off to each of the individual stories but would also contain information of the whys and hows of the DVD box set (why it was released as such, how it's marketed overseas/in the UK) something like that. That was it could be a nicely referenced page along with links to the individual DVD story pages. --[[User:Tangerineduel|Tangerineduel]] 13:39, 3 November 2007 (UTC) | |||