Talk:Kate Stewart: Difference between revisions
m (→Doris the step mother: fix signature) |
|||
| Line 29: | Line 29: | ||
Due to the lack of a valid source, Doris therefore cannot stay in the main body of the article, much less the lead. {{user:CzechOut/Sig}}{{User:CzechOut/TimeFormat}} 16:42: Sat 26 Jan 2013</span> | Due to the lack of a valid source, Doris therefore cannot stay in the main body of the article, much less the lead. {{user:CzechOut/Sig}}{{User:CzechOut/TimeFormat}} 16:42: Sat 26 Jan 2013</span> | ||
:I'm unable to find a dictionary that defines "stepmother" as narrowly as you do. Oxford defines it simply as "a woman who is married to one’s father after the divorce of one’s parents or the death of one’s mother." Can you cite a source for your definition? -- | :I'm unable to find a dictionary that defines "stepmother" as narrowly as you do. Oxford defines it simply as "a woman who is married to one’s father after the divorce of one’s parents or the death of one’s mother." Can you cite a source for your definition? -- [[User:Rowan Earthwood|Rowan Earthwood]] [[User talk:Rowan Earthwood|<span title="Talk to me">☎</span>]] 16:57, January 26, 2013 (UTC) | ||
Revision as of 16:57, 26 January 2013
Age during The Silurians
When I encountered it, article had this statement:
- Kate was five at the time of the Wenley Moor Silurian incident. (PROSE: Doctor Who and the Cave-Monsters)
Well, I've searched the book seven ways from Sunday, and all of the following search terms have failed:
- Kate
- Katherine
- Katarina
- daughter
- Fiona
- "five years"
- "5 years"
- "age of five"
- kid
- child
None of them turn up a hint of anything to do with a daughter of the Brig. Thus, I've removed this sentence because the citation is clearly wrong. If anyone knows where the statement actually comes from, they're free to reinsert it, along with the proper citation.
czechout<staff /> ☎ ✍ 00:40: Sun 23 Sep 2012
I think it might be from The Scales of Injustice. Doug86 ☎ 00:43, September 23, 2012 (UTC)
'Kate was the daughter',,, isn't that supposed to be 'is the daughter'. She hasn't died yet has she?
- We write everything in past tense here. 170.185.224.19talk to me 13:34, September 24, 2012 (UTC)
Doris the step mother
The lead asserted that Doris Lethbridge-Stewart was Kate's step-mother. That's pure speculation, since new spouses of non-custodial natural parents are not automatically considered step-parents. There's no way in hell my mother would consider her father's wife her "step-mother" in any sense, and I certainly don't think of her as my "step-grandmother". "Step-parent" is not a legal title that simply passes automatically upon a marriage certificate. Step parents have no legally-enforceable parental responsibilities until and unless they actually adopt the child, at which point they are no longer step-parents.
You have to essentially earn the title "step-mother", so we would need to have narrative evidence that there was some sort of positive relationship between Kate and Doris. We've got good evidence from Scales of Injustice that Fiona was her natural and custodial mother. As far as I'm aware, there isn't any evidence in any story that Kate had any sort of interaction with Doris.
Due to the lack of a valid source, Doris therefore cannot stay in the main body of the article, much less the lead.
czechout<staff /> ☎ ✍ 16:42: Sat 26 Jan 2013
- I'm unable to find a dictionary that defines "stepmother" as narrowly as you do. Oxford defines it simply as "a woman who is married to one’s father after the divorce of one’s parents or the death of one’s mother." Can you cite a source for your definition? -- Rowan Earthwood ☎ 16:57, January 26, 2013 (UTC)
