Talk:Penelope Gate: Difference between revisions
From Tardis Wiki, the free Doctor Who reference
OttselSpy25 (talk | contribs) |
OttselSpy25 (talk | contribs) |
||
| Line 4: | Line 4: | ||
:Well, to be fair, Penelope Gate is the only character who has been specifically identified ''in-universe'' as being the Doctor's mother. It's the same with [[Ulysses]] as being the Doctor's father. So even if Colfer didn't intend to refer to Penelope when he wrote the e-book, I see no problem with the information from ''[[A Big Hand for the Doctor (short story)|A Big Hand for the Doctor]]'' being added to this page. I can see how their would be a problem with adding information about [[The Woman (The End of Time)|The Woman]], given that there was no in-universe confirmation of her identity. [[User:Slughorn42|Slughorn42]] [[User talk:Slughorn42|<span title="Talk to me">☎</span>]] 03:40, January 27, 2013 (UTC) | :Well, to be fair, Penelope Gate is the only character who has been specifically identified ''in-universe'' as being the Doctor's mother. It's the same with [[Ulysses]] as being the Doctor's father. So even if Colfer didn't intend to refer to Penelope when he wrote the e-book, I see no problem with the information from ''[[A Big Hand for the Doctor (short story)|A Big Hand for the Doctor]]'' being added to this page. I can see how their would be a problem with adding information about [[The Woman (The End of Time)|The Woman]], given that there was no in-universe confirmation of her identity. [[User:Slughorn42|Slughorn42]] [[User talk:Slughorn42|<span title="Talk to me">☎</span>]] 03:40, January 27, 2013 (UTC) | ||
::[edit conflict] | ::[edit conflict] | ||
: But, as it were, Penelope Gate is, "The Doctor's Mother". She is the only person in the DWU ever called that, other than [[The Woman (The End of Time)|The Woman]], thus any reference to "The Doctor's Mother" is referencing towards the ''idea'' of "The Doctor's Mother", a concept currently only held by [[Penelope Gate]]. Basically, Penelope Grant is the only identity of "The Doctor's Mother" we've ever known, other than [[Loom|the odd sewing machine]], and so any reference to "The Doctor's Mother" must be "Penelope Gate". [[User:OttselSpy25|OS25]] ([[User Talk:OttselSpy25|talk to me, baby.]]) 03:46, January 27, 2013 (UTC) | : But, as it were, Penelope Gate is, "The Doctor's Mother". She is the only person in the DWU ever called that, other than [[The Woman (The End of Time)|The Woman]], thus any reference to "The Doctor's Mother" is referencing towards the ''idea'' of "The Doctor's Mother", a concept currently only held by [[Penelope Gate]]. Basically, Penelope Grant is the only identity of "The Doctor's Mother" we've ever known, other than [[Loom|the odd sewing machine]], and so any reference to "The Doctor's Mother" must be "Penelope Gate". | ||
:I could see someone wanting to split up if there were multiple identities to the Doctor's mother, but there aren't. There has only ever been one identity to her. And that's Penelope. It's like if [[Scared Man]] got his own spin-off and got the name "John Jenkins". John Jenkins and Scared Man aren't then separate entities, they're both the same person. "The Doctor's Mother" got a name in a spinn-off book and it was "Penelope Grate", and there's no reason to make separate pages for those two names. [[User:OttselSpy25|OS25]] ([[User Talk:OttselSpy25|talk to me, baby.]]) 03:46, January 27, 2013 (UTC) | |||
Revision as of 03:52, 27 January 2013
Givin' a red card to this page
What in the world is going on with this page? How have we conflated every reference to "the Doctor's mother" to Penelope Gale? We're making all sorts of assertions that cannot be supported just because there's a redirect from "the Doctor's mother" to Penelope Gale. There's no way that Eoin Colfer is making a reference to Penelope Gale in A Big Hand for the Doctor. This information is getting conflated simply because OttselSpy25 created a redirect to this page. There is, I would submit, a difference between Penelope Gale and the general concept of "the Doctor's mother".
czechout<staff /> ☎ ✍ 03:27: Sun 27 Jan 2013
- Well, to be fair, Penelope Gate is the only character who has been specifically identified in-universe as being the Doctor's mother. It's the same with Ulysses as being the Doctor's father. So even if Colfer didn't intend to refer to Penelope when he wrote the e-book, I see no problem with the information from A Big Hand for the Doctor being added to this page. I can see how their would be a problem with adding information about The Woman, given that there was no in-universe confirmation of her identity. Slughorn42 ☎ 03:40, January 27, 2013 (UTC)
- [edit conflict]
- But, as it were, Penelope Gate is, "The Doctor's Mother". She is the only person in the DWU ever called that, other than The Woman, thus any reference to "The Doctor's Mother" is referencing towards the idea of "The Doctor's Mother", a concept currently only held by Penelope Gate. Basically, Penelope Grant is the only identity of "The Doctor's Mother" we've ever known, other than the odd sewing machine, and so any reference to "The Doctor's Mother" must be "Penelope Gate".
- I could see someone wanting to split up if there were multiple identities to the Doctor's mother, but there aren't. There has only ever been one identity to her. And that's Penelope. It's like if Scared Man got his own spin-off and got the name "John Jenkins". John Jenkins and Scared Man aren't then separate entities, they're both the same person. "The Doctor's Mother" got a name in a spinn-off book and it was "Penelope Grate", and there's no reason to make separate pages for those two names. OS25 (talk to me, baby.) 03:46, January 27, 2013 (UTC)
