Talk:Harry Sullivan: Difference between revisions
(Created page with "==Harry's Final Fate == There are conflicting accounts of Harry's later fate. In the below biography, it is established both that Sarah Jane met with Harry during 2010, and also …") |
No edit summary |
||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
==Harry's Final Fate == | ==Harry's Final Fate == | ||
There are conflicting accounts of Harry's later fate. In the below biography, it is established both that Sarah Jane met with Harry during 2010, and also that he died before 2009! At least one of these (if not both) is false; the novellisation of ''the Wedding of Sarah Jane Smith ''differs slightly from the actual episode so could be discarded as not true, but the 2010-meetings source has no mention of her world-saving adventures as portrayed in ''The Sarah Jane Adventures''. Therefore I am re-labelling these parts under "possible fates" [[Special:Contributions/82.42.249.145|82.42.249.145]] 20:58, January 8, 2011 (UTC) | There are conflicting accounts of Harry's later fate. In the below biography, it is established both that Sarah Jane met with Harry during 2010, and also that he died before 2009! At least one of these (if not both) is false; the novellisation of ''the Wedding of Sarah Jane Smith ''differs slightly from the actual episode so could be discarded as not true, but the 2010-meetings source has no mention of her world-saving adventures as portrayed in ''The Sarah Jane Adventures''. Therefore I am re-labelling these parts under "possible fates" [[Special:Contributions/82.42.249.145|82.42.249.145]] 20:58, January 8, 2011 (UTC) | ||
There is no contradiction. The SJS audio in question takes place in 2006, and in it Sarah Jane already says that Harry is missing in action, and while they used to meet in that place every year, by then she has been coming there for some time alone in hope of seeing her again. And according to the article about it, the "Wedding..." novelisation also mentions her believing him to be dead or missing in action too, not certain that he's dead. Therefore him being alive by 2015 according to the Virgin novel is also not a contradiction. [[Special:Contributions/78.9.7.155|78.9.7.155]]<sup>[[User talk:78.9.7.155#top|talk to me]]</sup> 20:06, April 11, 2013 (UTC) | |||
Revision as of 20:06, 11 April 2013
Harry's Final Fate
There are conflicting accounts of Harry's later fate. In the below biography, it is established both that Sarah Jane met with Harry during 2010, and also that he died before 2009! At least one of these (if not both) is false; the novellisation of the Wedding of Sarah Jane Smith differs slightly from the actual episode so could be discarded as not true, but the 2010-meetings source has no mention of her world-saving adventures as portrayed in The Sarah Jane Adventures. Therefore I am re-labelling these parts under "possible fates" 82.42.249.145 20:58, January 8, 2011 (UTC)
There is no contradiction. The SJS audio in question takes place in 2006, and in it Sarah Jane already says that Harry is missing in action, and while they used to meet in that place every year, by then she has been coming there for some time alone in hope of seeing her again. And according to the article about it, the "Wedding..." novelisation also mentions her believing him to be dead or missing in action too, not certain that he's dead. Therefore him being alive by 2015 according to the Virgin novel is also not a contradiction. 78.9.7.155talk to me 20:06, April 11, 2013 (UTC)
