198
edits
no edit summary
Phil Stone (talk | contribs) No edit summary |
No edit summary |
||
| Line 65: | Line 65: | ||
I am not convinced. Perhaps ther is no explanation for the voice. No explanation how someone could out do the "combined hordes of Ghengis Khan." But I suspect that if we ever learn who started the Silence on their quest, we will have more insight into the voice.[[User:Phil Stone|Phil Stone]] [[User talk:Phil Stone|<span title="Talk to me">☎</span>]] 05:09, June 15, 2013 (UTC) | I am not convinced. Perhaps ther is no explanation for the voice. No explanation how someone could out do the "combined hordes of Ghengis Khan." But I suspect that if we ever learn who started the Silence on their quest, we will have more insight into the voice.[[User:Phil Stone|Phil Stone]] [[User talk:Phil Stone|<span title="Talk to me">☎</span>]] 05:09, June 15, 2013 (UTC) | ||
: I continue to be amazed at how little credit members of this site give to The Silence. The "Silents" claim to have been guiding humanity since fire and the wheel and imply a hand in any and all major human discoveries and all to serve whatever they need. The Doctor may say that the Silents don't do anything for themselves but let's be honest the Doctor is no more immune to the effect of The Silence than anyone else. He can't remember then so whatever he says about the is an assumption and even Steven Moffat can't get around that. The Silents may have become hidden overseers over time but whatever the Silents want doing they must have the knowledge of how to make that into a possibility or else they're at a dead end. | |||
: Therefore either the Silents are super omniscient and just know everything or else they've already been through that journey and learned it all. They could do it all in principle they just can't or won't in practice. Either way we can not be dealing with foolish beings their degree of success tells against that. | |||
: Further whatever they do they do must serve the purposes of The Silence which appears to be preventing the Doctor answering the question on Trenzalore, therefore it's not unreasonable to imagine that all their engagements with humans are directed towards that goal however hard that is to conceive. | |||
: The Silence clearly has technology that far outstrips the best of human technology on Earth, yet the Doctor said that the only reason that human being decided to visit the moon in 1969 was because The Silence need a spacesuit. That suggest a spectacular lack of imaginative initiative on behalf of humanity. The Silence have actually interstellar travel and presumably time travel technology. Why do they need humans to make them a spacesuit, there must be loads available to them. And if they if they do need it made by humans why at that time? Isn't it just as likely humans decided to go to the moon in 1969 and the Silents decided to infiltrate the enterprise? | |||
: These being are not stupid, if they did blow the TARDIS it was no act of carelessness. The reason this failure to resolve the TARDIS explosion so gets on people's nerves and tries their patience is that at the end of Series 5 was that the explosion of the TARDIS was a willful attack on space-time by an unknown agency by attacking it at its weakest point; which happened to be Amy and Rory's wedding day. | |||
But the Pandorica is what interests me the most because it is most interest because although the allience may not have realized it putting the Doctor in the Pandorica meant that the one man who could save the universe was the only man who was protected from its destruction when it ended. Without the Doctor and the Pandorica, space-time could not have been saved.[[User:DCT|DCT]] [[User talk:DCT|<span title="Talk to me">☎</span>]] 16:00, June 15, 2013 (UTC) | |||