Talk:The Rulers of the Universe (audio story): Difference between revisions

Talk:The Rulers of the Universe (audio story) (edit)

Revision as of 12:08, 15 April 2016

No change in size , 15 April 2016

m

→‎Placement before or after The Husbands of River Song

Amorkuz

25,433

edits

@@ Line 3: / Line 3: @@
 A disagreement occurred regarding whether River could refer in this story to her crashing into a planet in ''[[The Husbands of River Song (TV story)|The Husbands of River Song]]''. Thus, before making further edits, I propose to discuss and come to a conclusion.
-'''[[User:Amorkuz|Amrokuz]]'s thoughts.''' In ''[[Forest of the Dead (TV story)|Forest of the Dead]]'', River says that before this trip the [[Twelfth Doctor]] gave her a sonic screwdriver and recalls their last meeting. It has been generally agreed that this last meeting happened in ''The Husbands of River Song''. Also her diary in ''The Husbands'' is almost full, meaning that almost no adventures happened after. I conclude that the adventures from ''The Diary'' happened for River before the ones from ''The Husbands''.
+'''[[User:Amorkuz|Amorkuz]]'s thoughts.''' In ''[[Forest of the Dead (TV story)|Forest of the Dead]]'', River says that before this trip the [[Twelfth Doctor]] gave her a sonic screwdriver and recalls their last meeting. It has been generally agreed that this last meeting happened in ''The Husbands of River Song''. Also her diary in ''The Husbands'' is almost full, meaning that almost no adventures happened after. I conclude that the adventures from ''The Diary'' happened for River before the ones from ''The Husbands''.
 '''[[[User:TheChampionOfTime|TheChampionOfTime]]'s thoughts''' (from a comment to an edit). "River uses her Sonic Screwdriver in these stories. How could this not take place after ''Husbands''?"
-'''[[User:Amorkuz|Amrokuz]]'s response.''' To the best of my memory, in the ''Diary'' tetralogy, River uses her [[sonic trowel]], which we see in ''The Husbands'' but which she must have had before that too. I cannot remember an indication that at some point River uses a sonic device other than the trowel. Usually, the sounds of a sonic device operating are heard without an additional comment, since the presence of the trowel is established in the first story of the box set.
+'''[[User:Amorkuz|Amorkuz]]'s response.''' To the best of my memory, in the ''Diary'' tetralogy, River uses her [[sonic trowel]], which we see in ''The Husbands'' but which she must have had before that too. I cannot remember an indication that at some point River uses a sonic device other than the trowel. Usually, the sounds of a sonic device operating are heard without an additional comment, since the presence of the trowel is established in the first story of the box set.
 Actually, the idea to identify the sonic devices is very good for determining whether River could have referred to ''The Husbands'' in ''The Diary''. River did not have a screwdriver before ''The Husbands'', and would naturally use it after. Could you point me to the place where the screwdriver is mentioned in ''The Diary''? [[User:Amorkuz|Amorkuz]] [[User talk:Amorkuz|<span title="Talk to me">☎</span>]] 12:07, April 15, 2016 (UTC)