Talk:Inferno (TV story): Difference between revisions
(Created page with ' ==Story Notes or Behind the Scenes?.== This article has a large and varied Story Notes section. Some of the entres would be more suitably placed within a Behind the Scenes sect…') |
Bluebox444 (talk | contribs) No edit summary |
||
| Line 3: | Line 3: | ||
==Story Notes or Behind the Scenes?.== | ==Story Notes or Behind the Scenes?.== | ||
This article has a large and varied Story Notes section. Some of the entres would be more suitably placed within a Behind the Scenes section, for instance the part about Barry Letts recieving sole credit for the story is not really part of the world of the story but is a real world event. Is this enough of a distinction to warrant adding a section in order to move entries? Some items might qualify for either section, such as the Caroline John with the gun issue; others cleary belong where they are. What constitutes a story note and what exactly is defined as 'Behind the Scenes'? Is there a guideline somewhere to reference what type of entry belongs where? Is it as simple as In universe items belong to the former and real world items belong to the latter? Probably not, but one can hope something simple and black&white is out there. Other issues could arise from trying to address this one. e.g. If a TV story has a deleted scene due to an artistic decision made on set or in the editing process, as opposed to one that simply hit the floor due to running time, which note would go where? Many other story pages have similar cases and overall the wiki would benifit by having entries properly re-placed. --[[User:Stillnotginger|Stillnotginger]] 11:10, February 20, 2010 (UTC) | This article has a large and varied Story Notes section. Some of the entres would be more suitably placed within a Behind the Scenes section, for instance the part about Barry Letts recieving sole credit for the story is not really part of the world of the story but is a real world event. Is this enough of a distinction to warrant adding a section in order to move entries? Some items might qualify for either section, such as the Caroline John with the gun issue; others cleary belong where they are. What constitutes a story note and what exactly is defined as 'Behind the Scenes'? Is there a guideline somewhere to reference what type of entry belongs where? Is it as simple as In universe items belong to the former and real world items belong to the latter? Probably not, but one can hope something simple and black&white is out there. Other issues could arise from trying to address this one. e.g. If a TV story has a deleted scene due to an artistic decision made on set or in the editing process, as opposed to one that simply hit the floor due to running time, which note would go where? Many other story pages have similar cases and overall the wiki would benifit by having entries properly re-placed. --[[User:Stillnotginger|Stillnotginger]] 11:10, February 20, 2010 (UTC) | ||
=="Dimensional paradoxes"?== | |||
I noticed a discrepancy between this serial and the Cybermen episodes of the new series on the topic of parallel universes. I put in what seems to be the most likely explanation - I think it makes sense. I don't know how the rest of Doctor Who continuity has dealt with this subject. --[[User:Bluebox444|Bluebox444]] 4:35. March 22, 2010 (EST) | |||
Revision as of 20:36, 22 March 2010
Story Notes or Behind the Scenes?.
This article has a large and varied Story Notes section. Some of the entres would be more suitably placed within a Behind the Scenes section, for instance the part about Barry Letts recieving sole credit for the story is not really part of the world of the story but is a real world event. Is this enough of a distinction to warrant adding a section in order to move entries? Some items might qualify for either section, such as the Caroline John with the gun issue; others cleary belong where they are. What constitutes a story note and what exactly is defined as 'Behind the Scenes'? Is there a guideline somewhere to reference what type of entry belongs where? Is it as simple as In universe items belong to the former and real world items belong to the latter? Probably not, but one can hope something simple and black&white is out there. Other issues could arise from trying to address this one. e.g. If a TV story has a deleted scene due to an artistic decision made on set or in the editing process, as opposed to one that simply hit the floor due to running time, which note would go where? Many other story pages have similar cases and overall the wiki would benifit by having entries properly re-placed. --Stillnotginger 11:10, February 20, 2010 (UTC)
"Dimensional paradoxes"?
I noticed a discrepancy between this serial and the Cybermen episodes of the new series on the topic of parallel universes. I put in what seems to be the most likely explanation - I think it makes sense. I don't know how the rest of Doctor Who continuity has dealt with this subject. --Bluebox444 4:35. March 22, 2010 (EST)
