Talk:Myloki: Difference between revisions

From Tardis Wiki, the free Doctor Who reference
No edit summary
Tag: 2017 source edit
Line 6: Line 6:


::Anastasia, you're right that between this page and Captain Scarlet's, our treatment of ''The Indestructible Man'' is inconsistent right now. The Myloki are explicitly a code name for the real species name in the novel, and if they weren't named, they would definitely qualify for the "Mysteron" page name with the {{tlx|conjecture}}, per the [[Talk:Legacies (short story)]] precedent often cited by [[User:Najawin|Najawin]] among others. Because of this, I think the fix to the inconsistency should be to merge [[Paul Metcalf]] and [[Grant Matthews]], as I illustrated at [[User:NateBumber/Sandbox/Captain Scarlet]], not to split this page. – [[User:NateBumber|n8]] ([[User talk:NateBumber|☎]]) 02:43, 25 October 2022 (UTC)
::Anastasia, you're right that between this page and Captain Scarlet's, our treatment of ''The Indestructible Man'' is inconsistent right now. The Myloki are explicitly a code name for the real species name in the novel, and if they weren't named, they would definitely qualify for the "Mysteron" page name with the {{tlx|conjecture}}, per the [[Talk:Legacies (short story)]] precedent often cited by [[User:Najawin|Najawin]] among others. Because of this, I think the fix to the inconsistency should be to merge [[Paul Metcalf]] and [[Grant Matthews]], as I illustrated at [[User:NateBumber/Sandbox/Captain Scarlet]], not to split this page. – [[User:NateBumber|n8]] ([[User talk:NateBumber|☎]]) 02:43, 25 October 2022 (UTC)
i apologise for my delay I do would take either as long as all the information for both pages was used as well as fleshing out the Mysteron segment of the hypothetical merge. The would also lead to several other mergers however such ad combining [[Conrad Turner]] and [[Captain Death]] as well as the various other Spectrum members as the SILOET stand ins. I do have one point against this though the fact that Several Characters are reminiscent of the characters from UFO and the moonbase Uniform from UFO is explicitly used, UFO a happens in the 1980’s not the 2060’s of the Supermarination of Captain Scarlet. Other minor contradictions include the events of Space 1999 being mentioned happening around the same time as the title suggest this show happens in 1999. However I would be 100% in favour of the merger is [[Ceol]] is merged with [[Kelsey Hooper]] as it seems to me the case is similar. Due to the Fact that not only are they implied to be the same (even more so than the Gerry Anderson Characters in the Indestructible man) I would argue that both the Indestructible Man Characters and Ceol deserve to be merged with their respective originals and to merge only the Gerry Anderson Charters would suggest, in My personal opinion a level of bias towards one group. I would stand by either decision to split this page or two merge all the IM/GA Characters along with pages like Ceol/ Kelsey. Once more I apologise for the lateness of my reply. It was due to several events as well as simply forgetting I posted here for a while. Sorry I will try not to do so again.[[User:Anastasia Cousins|Anastasia Cousins]] [[User talk:Anastasia Cousins|<span title="Talk to me">☎</span>]] 20:57, 16 November 2022 (UTC)

Revision as of 20:57, 16 November 2022

Split?

Should this page be split as the Mysterons link here, I know that the Myloki are an expy of the Mysterons but the Mysterons played a core part in the later TV21 strips and if Captain Scarlet has a separate page to their indestructible man version should not the Mysterons then get one? Anastasia Cousins 21:13, 24 October 2022 (UTC)

I see no reason not to. Cookieboy 2005 21:20, 24 October 2022 (UTC)
Anastasia, you're right that between this page and Captain Scarlet's, our treatment of The Indestructible Man is inconsistent right now. The Myloki are explicitly a code name for the real species name in the novel, and if they weren't named, they would definitely qualify for the "Mysteron" page name with the {{conjecture}}, per the Talk:Legacies (short story) precedent often cited by Najawin among others. Because of this, I think the fix to the inconsistency should be to merge Paul Metcalf and Grant Matthews, as I illustrated at User:NateBumber/Sandbox/Captain Scarlet, not to split this page. – n8 () 02:43, 25 October 2022 (UTC)

i apologise for my delay I do would take either as long as all the information for both pages was used as well as fleshing out the Mysteron segment of the hypothetical merge. The would also lead to several other mergers however such ad combining Conrad Turner and Captain Death as well as the various other Spectrum members as the SILOET stand ins. I do have one point against this though the fact that Several Characters are reminiscent of the characters from UFO and the moonbase Uniform from UFO is explicitly used, UFO a happens in the 1980’s not the 2060’s of the Supermarination of Captain Scarlet. Other minor contradictions include the events of Space 1999 being mentioned happening around the same time as the title suggest this show happens in 1999. However I would be 100% in favour of the merger is Ceol is merged with Kelsey Hooper as it seems to me the case is similar. Due to the Fact that not only are they implied to be the same (even more so than the Gerry Anderson Characters in the Indestructible man) I would argue that both the Indestructible Man Characters and Ceol deserve to be merged with their respective originals and to merge only the Gerry Anderson Charters would suggest, in My personal opinion a level of bias towards one group. I would stand by either decision to split this page or two merge all the IM/GA Characters along with pages like Ceol/ Kelsey. Once more I apologise for the lateness of my reply. It was due to several events as well as simply forgetting I posted here for a while. Sorry I will try not to do so again.Anastasia Cousins 20:57, 16 November 2022 (UTC)