User:SOTO/Forum Archive/The Panopticon/@comment-25041817-20151024182247/@comment-25041817-20151024201807

Bold Clone wrote: Simple. The only stuff which belongs on any Doctor's page is events actually involving that incarnation. Having a section on the Third Doctor's page which says "The Second Doctor almost regenerated but didn't" doesn't make any sense. As Mewiet said, a "near-miss" is really part of the previous incarnation's bio. It doesn't belong on the subsequent Doctor's page. Specifically, in the case of "The Touch of the Nurazh" (if you had actually taken the time to read the section), you can see it explains that 3 actually regenerates into 4, but then the not-quite-finished-regeneration is undone. So the stuff stays on 4's page, since it involved 4. In "The Indestructible Man" (which apparently you didn't read) 2 did not actually regenerate into 3. So the material is removed, since 3 wasn't involved. The exact same goes for "The Stolen Earth", which is why there was no reason given for it. 10 really does go through the regeneration process, but he does not regenerate into 11. 11 is not involved (and the situation has absolutely nothing to do with "The Touch of the Nurazh" in any way because only one form of the Doctor is involved), so the incident is removed from 11's page.

I'm going to be the mature one here and overlook that offensive comment about not reading them, which I did.

Anyway, I can see the point your making and I concede with your logic. So, I'll just love you and leave then.