→Removing speculation
(Reasoning for removing speculation) |
|||
| Line 785: | Line 785: | ||
==Removing speculation== | ==Removing speculation== | ||
I removed the continuity section explaining how this relates to Flesh and Stone partly because I think it's wrong but also because I think it's inappropriate. | I removed the continuity section explaining how this relates to Flesh and Stone partly because I think it's wrong but also because I think it's inappropriate. | ||
There is no evidence that the cracks never happened. Yes we see them close, but we don’t see them not open in the first place. | There is no evidence that the cracks never happened. Yes we see them close, but we don’t see them not open in the first place. | ||
For River Song, Flesh and Stone takes place after The Pandorica Opens/The Big Bang. All the events of those episodes have already happened for her including the erasure/recreation of the Doctor, and the close of the cracks. Therefore there are still cracks in the universe: they open, erase people, then close. Consequently the angels are still destroyed by the crack and there is no need to invoke a new version of these events. | For River Song, Flesh and Stone takes place after The Pandorica Opens/The Big Bang. All the events of those episodes have already happened for her including the erasure/recreation of the Doctor, and the close of the cracks. Therefore there are still cracks in the universe: they open, erase people, then close. Consequently the angels are still destroyed by the crack and there is no need to invoke a new version of these events. | ||
However, I imagine some people disagree. There are a variety of interpretations as to how the episodes interact and I don’t think we should be peddling one particular interpretation as the correct one. Better to remove the reference entirely and let people decide what they want.[[User:LordJuss|LordJuss]] 12:25, July 9, 2010 (UTC) | However, I imagine some people disagree. There are a variety of interpretations as to how the episodes interact and I don’t think we should be peddling one particular interpretation as the correct one. Better to remove the reference entirely and let people decide what they want.[[User:LordJuss|LordJuss]] 12:25, July 9, 2010 (UTC) | ||
This is the way I see it too - with her comment at the end of Flesh and Stone "you'll see me again when the Pandorica Opens" suggest it happens anyway - you got to remember that happened in the doctors past before he closed the cracks so in that perspective it will still happen for river even though its in her future [[Special:Contributions/91.108.34.210|91.108.34.210]] 15:33, July 9, 2010 (UTC) | |||