Howling:River / Rory: Difference between revisions

From Tardis Wiki, the free Doctor Who reference
No edit summary
No edit summary
Line 21: Line 21:
Please quote your source, I highly doubt we know she had 30 adventures with the Doctor before she visited the wedding...especially when she said the Doctor doesn't know her yet before launching him into the exploding TARDIS and the fact that she needed the Vortex Manipulator to leave afterward...I'm so sick and tired of people like you who just keep speculating and assume things without supports. --[[Special:Contributions/203.168.176.42|[[Special:Contributions/203.168.176.42|203.168.176.42]] 20:16, July 31, 2010 (UTC)]]
Please quote your source, I highly doubt we know she had 30 adventures with the Doctor before she visited the wedding...especially when she said the Doctor doesn't know her yet before launching him into the exploding TARDIS and the fact that she needed the Vortex Manipulator to leave afterward...I'm so sick and tired of people like you who just keep speculating and assume things without supports. --[[Special:Contributions/203.168.176.42|[[Special:Contributions/203.168.176.42|203.168.176.42]] 20:16, July 31, 2010 (UTC)]]


::This is the howling. We're allowed to speculate here... that's the whole point of it. If you're sick and tired of speculation then go to one of the other forums.  
::This is the howling. We're allowed to speculate here... that's the whole point of it. If you're sick and tired of speculation then go to one of the other forums.
::I never said she ''did'' have 30 adventures. Both times I have made sure not to say that anything is definite; "Her timeline '''could''' easily be" and "For all we know". And yes, the Doctor wouldn't know her yet, in his timeline... they meet at different points where each knows a certain amount of information about the other. [[User:The Thirteenth Doctor|The Thirteenth Doctor]] 20:18, July 31, 2010 (UTC)
::I never said she ''did'' have 30 adventures. Both times I have made sure not to say that anything is definite; "Her timeline '''could''' easily be" and "For all we know". And yes, the Doctor wouldn't know her yet, in his timeline... they meet at different points where each knows a certain amount of information about the other. [[User:The Thirteenth Doctor|The Thirteenth Doctor]] 20:18, July 31, 2010 (UTC)
::
::There are speculations that are helpful because they are based on what we know...and there are speculations that are not helpful because they contradict what we know:
::*The Doctor doesn't exist following Big Bang 2
::*River's blue book was blank because the Doctor never existed
::*River's blue book was blank when she gave it to Amy
::*according to your timeline, River's adventure with the Doctor happened during the time when the Doctor didn't exist...how does it make perfect sense?  Stop throwing in random comments without thoughts --[[Special:Contributions/203.168.176.42|203.168.176.42]] 21:09, July 31, 2010 (UTC)

Revision as of 21:09, 31 July 2010

The Howling → River / Rory
There be spoilers about un-released stories here.
Run back to the forums if you're scared.

One thing is intriguing me. It is confirmed that River Song will appear in Series 6. and Rory is now travelling with the doctor along with Amy. So Rory and River are supposed to meet. Moreover, River told the doctor in the end of "The Big Bang" that soon he will find out who she is, so what happens in series 6 already happened in River's timeline. So why didnt she recognize Rory when she saw him in "Pandorica Opens"? Does this mean that Rory won't last during all the series? but he's Amy's husband so the only way he will leave her is that he dies.. Would Moffat kill him again?

P.S. Please no one starts talking about River being Amy or Rose or whatever.. River is River she's a new character..63.216.116.9 19:10, July 31, 2010 (UTC)

  • Well, we don't know how long or how many adventures River had after the universe was reset but before she visited Amy's wedding. Her timeline could easily be:
  1. Pre-Pandorica events
  2. Pandorica Opens (not knowing Rory but meeting him)
  3. Resetting of universe and series 6 events (she would now know Rory)
  4. Crash of the Byzantium
  5. Picnick/Singing towers/Library etc.

Also, it could just as easily be that Rory leaves the TARDIS and visits family etc... The Thirteenth Doctor 19:28, July 31, 2010 (UTC)


Your timeline part doesn't answer the question at all: as what you labelled "pre-Pandorica events" is going to happen very soon according to what 63 said. --222.166.181.144 19:37, July 31, 2010 (UTC)

  • It makes perfect sense. All we know is that the River at the wedding had already lived the series 6 events. We don't know when or where River came from. For all we know she had 30 adventures with the Doctor before she visited the wedding. The Thirteenth Doctor 19:42, July 31, 2010 (UTC)

Please quote your source, I highly doubt we know she had 30 adventures with the Doctor before she visited the wedding...especially when she said the Doctor doesn't know her yet before launching him into the exploding TARDIS and the fact that she needed the Vortex Manipulator to leave afterward...I'm so sick and tired of people like you who just keep speculating and assume things without supports. --[[Special:Contributions/203.168.176.42|203.168.176.42 20:16, July 31, 2010 (UTC)]]

This is the howling. We're allowed to speculate here... that's the whole point of it. If you're sick and tired of speculation then go to one of the other forums.
I never said she did have 30 adventures. Both times I have made sure not to say that anything is definite; "Her timeline could easily be" and "For all we know". And yes, the Doctor wouldn't know her yet, in his timeline... they meet at different points where each knows a certain amount of information about the other. The Thirteenth Doctor 20:18, July 31, 2010 (UTC)
There are speculations that are helpful because they are based on what we know...and there are speculations that are not helpful because they contradict what we know:
  • The Doctor doesn't exist following Big Bang 2
  • River's blue book was blank because the Doctor never existed
  • River's blue book was blank when she gave it to Amy
  • according to your timeline, River's adventure with the Doctor happened during the time when the Doctor didn't exist...how does it make perfect sense? Stop throwing in random comments without thoughts --203.168.176.42 21:09, July 31, 2010 (UTC)