More actions
Howling:The little girl is Lucy Saxon?!?! (view source)
Revision as of 10:25, 9 May 2011
, 9 May 2011no edit summary
No edit summary |
No edit summary |
||
| Line 10: | Line 10: | ||
I doubt that the little girl is Lucy Saxon, because I don't think that Moffat would want to bring up such a random plot point from the Davies era. Apart from that, although there was a lot left unexplained regarding Lucy's character, it didn't seem like there was anything particularly special about her. It seemed like she was just an innocent Human who the Master corrupted and abused, who later betrayed him. She also talked about her father in both episodes, and based on what we know about the girl so far, which is admittedly not a lot, she wouldn't have a father who knows she exists in 2008. It also isn't likely that Jenny will be returning played by a different actress. In ''The Doctor's Daughter'' they went out of their way to explain that Jenny couldn't regenerate, and when she did come back to life her appearance didn't change, so if they brought her back it would make more sense to keep the same actress.[[User:Icecreamdif|Icecreamdif]] 04:19, May 9, 2011 (UTC) | I doubt that the little girl is Lucy Saxon, because I don't think that Moffat would want to bring up such a random plot point from the Davies era. Apart from that, although there was a lot left unexplained regarding Lucy's character, it didn't seem like there was anything particularly special about her. It seemed like she was just an innocent Human who the Master corrupted and abused, who later betrayed him. She also talked about her father in both episodes, and based on what we know about the girl so far, which is admittedly not a lot, she wouldn't have a father who knows she exists in 2008. It also isn't likely that Jenny will be returning played by a different actress. In ''The Doctor's Daughter'' they went out of their way to explain that Jenny couldn't regenerate, and when she did come back to life her appearance didn't change, so if they brought her back it would make more sense to keep the same actress.[[User:Icecreamdif|Icecreamdif]] 04:19, May 9, 2011 (UTC) | ||
: I'm beginning to think you don't actually watch the show, or read the posts you reply to. | |||
: They never went out of their way to explain that Jenny couldn't regenerate, or anything like it. In fact, they established clearly that she had Gallifreyan physiology; the only way in which she wasn't a Time Lady is that "A real Time Lord is so much more... a sum of knowledge, a code, a shared history, a shared suffering". The Doctor clearly expected that she'd be able to regenerate when she was shot. After she didn't do so right away, he guessed (actually, Martha convinced him) that for some reason she couldn't--but then he also guessed that she couldn't come back to life in any other way. He was obviously wrong about one or the other. | |||
: As for which one, we don't really know. In Confidential and later interviews and writings, RTD was always coy about it. He said that it wasn't "necessarily" regeneration; he once called it "rejuvenation"; he explained how they intentionally shot it in the style of the TV movie regeneration instead of the new series to keep people guessing. | |||
: As for why they'd have a different actress play her, I already explained above that Georgia Moffet was noticeably pregnant, so if they wanted to bring her back they wouldn't have much choice--unless they wanted to give the Doctor a new granddaughter. | |||
: I still don't think it's likely, for the reasons I gave above (mainly, no good evidence)--but it's not impossible, and coming up with "proofs" that have nothing to do with reality is just silly. --[[Special:Contributions/99.33.26.0|99.33.26.0]] 06:28, May 9, 2011 (UTC) | |||
PPS, here's [http://www.marcusevanskma.com/Artistsdetails.asp?AType=2&Asx=2&artistID=306 the link] that shows that Catrin Stewart is playing a character named "Jenny" on Doctor Who. Again, the only evidence I've seen that it's the same Jenny that Georgia Moffett played is the fact that IMDB linked both characters, along with the maid from Human Nature, to the same character page, which doesn't prove much of anything. (Someone on one of the blogs also pointed out that she looks kind of Matt Smith-ish, in the same way that Georgia looked kind of David Tennant-ish. I'm not sure I see either resemblance, but I guess this proves that Matt will dump his girlfriend and marry Catrin, right?) --[[Special:Contributions/99.33.26.0|99.33.26.0]] 10:25, May 9, 2011 (UTC) | |||