More actions
Howling:Cross Dimensional niggle (Curse of Black Spot) (view source)
Revision as of 18:04, 15 August 2011
, 15 August 2011no edit summary
No edit summary |
No edit summary |
||
Line 13: | Line 13: | ||
Jack surely <b>would</b> have been given a larger role but that doesn't mean Avery and Toby weren't added to the script because he couldn't appear. If Jack had been there, it's extremely likely that use would have been made of him being "killed" and then taking the opposition by surprise, afterwards (as in <i>Journey's End</i>). No other character could do that. Avery and Toby wouldn't and couldn't simply have been "slotted in" to do everything Jack would have done. They could, though, have been written in, <b>in a reduced capacity</b>, to make up the numbers of those the Doctor recruited to his cause. | Jack surely <b>would</b> have been given a larger role but that doesn't mean Avery and Toby weren't added to the script because he couldn't appear. If Jack had been there, it's extremely likely that use would have been made of him being "killed" and then taking the opposition by surprise, afterwards (as in <i>Journey's End</i>). No other character could do that. Avery and Toby wouldn't and couldn't simply have been "slotted in" to do everything Jack would have done. They could, though, have been written in, <b>in a reduced capacity</b>, to make up the numbers of those the Doctor recruited to his cause. | ||
On the interdimensional question: Given the established situation that "parallel worlds are closed off", either that has changed and we've not been told so, yet, or what the Doctor meant by "an alternate dimension" isn't the same as an alternate universe. The latter seems more likely, especially as one of the first things established in the show (on 23rd November 1963) is that the interior of the TARDIS is in a different dimension from the exterior. Until/unless it's stated otherwise, I'll assume that Avery's (new) ship was in a different dimension <b>of the same universe</b> and can move between dimensions but not universes. --[[Special:Contributions/89.240.245.226|89.240.245.226]] 09:25, August 14, 2011 (UTC) | On the interdimensional question: Given the established situation that "parallel worlds are closed off", either that has changed and we've not been told so, yet, or what the Doctor meant by "an alternate dimension" isn't the same as an alternate universe. The latter seems more likely, especially as one of the first things established in the show (on 23rd November 1963) is that the interior of the TARDIS is in a different dimension from the exterior. Until/unless it's stated otherwise, I'll assume that Avery's (new) ship was in a different dimension <b>of the same universe</b> and can move between dimensions but not universes. --[[Special:Contributions/89.240.245.226|89.240.245.226]] 09:25, August 14, 2011 (UTC) | ||
I had assumed it was b), and that because the crew were dead, something had gone wrong during hyperspace travel, leaving the ship marooned at the same coordinates as the pirate ship, but somehow in other dimensions as well (just as the TARDIS is dimensionally transcendant). Then when the Doctor repaired the ship, he managed to bring it out of hyperspace and back into the normal universe (I assumed this because the Captain mentions heading for ORions Belt IIRC, which I took to mean it was back in our dimensions). [[Special:Contributions/187.58.98.57|187.58.98.57]] 18:04, August 15, 2011 (UTC) |