Forum:Is in-character linking narration canonical?: Difference between revisions
From Tardis Wiki, the free Doctor Who reference
No edit summary |
No edit summary |
||
| Line 6: | Line 6: | ||
:Should we include/count the linking narration done for the missing soundtracks? | :Should we include/count the linking narration done for the missing soundtracks? | ||
:I don't think it does count as it's deliberately framed as narration, I'd add a however this though, ''if'' a story comes along and (somehow) manages to frame it into a story then ''maybe'' it could be counted. But as it stands there doesn't seem to be enough information for this to be a valid image. --[[User:Tangerineduel|Tangerineduel]] / '''[[User talk:Tangerineduel|talk]]''' 16:29, August 21, 2011 (UTC) | :I don't think it does count as it's deliberately framed as narration, I'd add a however this though, ''if'' a story comes along and (somehow) manages to frame it into a story then ''maybe'' it could be counted. But as it stands there doesn't seem to be enough information for this to be a valid image. --[[User:Tangerineduel|Tangerineduel]] / '''[[User talk:Tangerineduel|talk]]''' 16:29, August 21, 2011 (UTC) | ||
::Just sticking to ''The Crusade'' for a minute, the thing is, that's a very different reconstruction to either Baker on ''Shada'' or Ford on ''Reign of Terror'' or Anneke Wills giving linking narration for ''Power of the Daleks'' on CD. Unlike these other cases, it's done as a scene with the character of Ian, not with the actor. It is Ian looking back on his life and remembering the story of how he got knighted by King Richard. It's released by the BBC, the tape's producers took the time to create a properly dressed and realistic set, and there's proper multiple-shot editing. It's in every sense a licensed narrative, and it does connect to the broader canon by confirming things that happened in other media. For instance, he references [[PDA]]: ''[[The Witch Hunters]]'', which was, at the time ''The Crusade'' VHS was released in [[1999]], the very latest story involving Ian. It just seems like there was a genuine effort to make the piece fit into continuity. {{user:CzechOut/Sig}} <span style="{{User:CzechOut/TimeFormat}}">'''04:11:34 Mon '''22 Aug 2011 </span> | |||
Revision as of 04:11, 22 August 2011
Index → Panopticon → Is in-character linking narration canonical?
Spoilers are strongly policed here.
If this thread's title doesn't specify it's spoilery, don't bring any up.
If this thread's title doesn't specify it's spoilery, don't bring any up.
So yanno how BBC Video used to release incomplete serials with linking narration to cover the lost episodes? Sometimes, that used an actor who wasn't in character providing the narration, as with Tom Baker on Shada. But The Crusade release has William Russell fully in character as Ian Chesterton. They even give him a lower third which reads, "Ian Chesterton". So is that a valid image of Ian? And if so, doesn't it counter the Death of the Doctor notion that Ian never aged? And to the extent that there are other in-character linking narrations, do we take them seriously?
czechout<staff /> ☎ ✍ <span style="">21:43:52 Thu 18 Aug 2011
- It's something outside of the original broadcast.
- Should we include/count the linking narration done for the missing soundtracks?
- I don't think it does count as it's deliberately framed as narration, I'd add a however this though, if a story comes along and (somehow) manages to frame it into a story then maybe it could be counted. But as it stands there doesn't seem to be enough information for this to be a valid image. --Tangerineduel / talk 16:29, August 21, 2011 (UTC)
- Just sticking to The Crusade for a minute, the thing is, that's a very different reconstruction to either Baker on Shada or Ford on Reign of Terror or Anneke Wills giving linking narration for Power of the Daleks on CD. Unlike these other cases, it's done as a scene with the character of Ian, not with the actor. It is Ian looking back on his life and remembering the story of how he got knighted by King Richard. It's released by the BBC, the tape's producers took the time to create a properly dressed and realistic set, and there's proper multiple-shot editing. It's in every sense a licensed narrative, and it does connect to the broader canon by confirming things that happened in other media. For instance, he references PDA: The Witch Hunters, which was, at the time The Crusade VHS was released in 1999, the very latest story involving Ian. It just seems like there was a genuine effort to make the piece fit into continuity.
czechout<staff /> ☎ ✍ <span style="">04:11:34 Mon 22 Aug 2011
- Just sticking to The Crusade for a minute, the thing is, that's a very different reconstruction to either Baker on Shada or Ford on Reign of Terror or Anneke Wills giving linking narration for Power of the Daleks on CD. Unlike these other cases, it's done as a scene with the character of Ian, not with the actor. It is Ian looking back on his life and remembering the story of how he got knighted by King Richard. It's released by the BBC, the tape's producers took the time to create a properly dressed and realistic set, and there's proper multiple-shot editing. It's in every sense a licensed narrative, and it does connect to the broader canon by confirming things that happened in other media. For instance, he references PDA: The Witch Hunters, which was, at the time The Crusade VHS was released in 1999, the very latest story involving Ian. It just seems like there was a genuine effort to make the piece fit into continuity.
