Diamond
Diamonds were a form of crystallized carbon and one of the most valuable substances in the universe.
In 1879, the Doctor used the infamous Koh-i-Noor diamond to kill a werewolf (DW: Tooth and Claw).
In 1909, while working for an unknown employer, Jack Harkness stole diamonds from a mine in Lahore. (torchwood.org.uk)
When Vislor Turlough won Enlightenment, he at first believed it to be a huge diamond. (DW: Enlightenment)
Diamonds were common on Telos, where the Cryons offered to pay Lytton and Griffiths in uncut diamonds in return for their services. (DW: Attack of the Cybermen)
The planet Midnight's surface was mostly diamonds, but since the planet went through harsh Xtonic radiation, the diamonds could not be excavated. (DW: Midnight)
In the 40th century, Baltazar attempted to compress the planet Earth into a diamond, but was stopped by the Doctor and Martha Jones. (DW: The Infinite Quest)
In the distant future, one of the Three Great Treasures of Generios was the largest diamond in existence, which was guarded by a Jelloid. (BFA: The One Doctor)
At the end of the Universe, it was believed that the skies of Utopia were made of diamonds. (DW: Utopia)