Howling:John Hurt is the Valeyard theory
So this is my 0,02$
When the Tenth doctor started regenerating at the end of ‘The Stolen Earth’ and subsequently diverted it to his ‘handy hand’. He explained it with: “I stopped it from going all the way and siphoned off the rest”. I think this means that he used a part of his regeneration energy to heal himself and then he put the rest (so the entire regeneration process that didn’t happen) into the hand thereby using an entire regeneration and essentially becoming the 11th doctor in the process. This could be confirmed by the fact that the remaining energy goes on to generate an entire new body from the hand and then rearranging Donna’s brain into that of a Time Lord. This would stand for both the physical and the mental parts of the regeneration.
This would make Matt Smith the 12th doctor which would contradict the doctor saying in ‘The Lodger’ that he is the 11th. However he is gesturing to his face at the time which could be seen as him saying that it’s his 11th face. This works out with the theory that Tennant is both the 10th and 11th doctor because he hasn’t changed his face. It could also be him saying that he is the eleventh regeneration cause he never says that he is the 11th doctor just the 11th.
Now the Master has said in Prose that the Valeyard would appear between the doctor’s ‘twelfth and final regeneration’ (I’ll come back to this) although we shouldn’t take this as automatically true, but what if we do? That would mean that somewhere after the twelfth doctor the valeyard would appear. If Matt Smith is the 12th that would mean that from now on the possibility of the valeyard returning is present. Also the Valeyard had a storyline where he manipulated the former versions of the doctor into changing his life which greatly resembles the plot of ‘The Name of the Doctor’ in which John Hurt first appears.
My guess is that Hurt is the Valeyard because the Valeyard can be said to go against the name of the doctor because of his egotism. The doctor being someone who would throw his own life away to help others. Also he has been described by the master as the amalgamation of the doctor’s dark side which would explain the dark setting where Clara finds Hurt.
End of theory
About the regeneration thing ‘between the twelfth and final regeneration’. How is this possible if the Time Lords have only twelve regenerations. I think this means that the doctor has absorbed at least a part of river’s regenerations thereby giving him an even more extended lifetime. Or it could be otherwise interpreted so that the Valeyard shows up on another time after the doctor’s 12 regenerations. The master saying this might mean we get to see more of him in the future *fingers crossed*.
Any thoughts on this would be great --145.53.128.150talk to me 21:56, June 13, 2013 (UTC)
- I haven't read the whole theory, but I thought the Master said in The Trial of a Time Lord (TV) that the Valeyard was from "between the Doctor's 12th and 13th lives", not regeneration events, meaning he appeared during the process of 12 regenerating into 13 (however that would happen). Just sayin'. —BioniclesaurKing4t2 - "Hello, I'm the Doctor. Basically, . . . run." 01:35, June 14, 2013 (UTC)
- Yup, between the "twelfth and final incarnation." See The Ultimate Foe ([1] and [2]). Andbeonetraveler ☎ 01:46, June 14, 2013 (UTC)
Another problem with "Hurt is Valeyard" is that Hurt seemed as if he was forced to be the one to take the fall for making a tough decision, though one he felt was needed and perhaps justified, a feeling which might have been part of the reason he lost the name "Doctor" (either by the others deciding or even by his own decision). By contrast, the Valeyard sounds more like a pure outright "bad guy", trying to sentence the Doctor for any crime he could. I just don't see them as having the same stories, which, as you know, "we all are in the end". And as for Journey's End 10 actually being 11, he may have "spent" the regeneration energy, but would he had to have actually "used" it on himself for it to count as one of his regenerations? Another potential loophole to exploit? —BioniclesaurKing4t2 - "Hello, I'm the Doctor. Basically, . . . run." 04:52, June 14, 2013 (UTC)
I was just making a post which said some of the same things. I dont think Hurt is the Valeyard. His interchange with the Doctor at the end of "Name.." was hardly what one would expect. The Doctor seemed to acknowledge that he had no alternatives, and didn't dispute that he was only motivated by a pursuit of peace and sanity. It is only at the use of the word "name" that the Doctor blanches.
Now perhaps it was not a real dialogue because they were not real to one another, and the Doctor saw no point in really taking him on because he did not think Hurt coould really hear him, or perhaps because Hurt in the timestream is only really a shado of Hurt. But it still doesn't sound to me like what the Doctor would say to the Valeyard.
I have said on other threads that I suspect Hurt is really the person with whom Porridge sympathizes,the person who pushed the button to end the CyberWar, at a very great cost of life. (Nightmare in Silver) Compare that action to the 9th Doctor, who had prepared a weapon which would have destroyed all the remaining Daleks, but he would not use it because it would also kill millions on Earth. First, do no harm, is the ancient code of the physician. If River is correct and we get our word "Doctor" from him, perhaps we also get the physician's moral code as well. If 9 had set off the device to defeat the Daleks, he would have broken the promise too.Phil Stone ☎ 05:26, June 14, 2013 (UTC
I allways suspected Porridge meant himself with the poor guy who had to push the button what with him being the emperor. It's true that the dialogue at the end of "The Name.." doesn't fit with the Valeyard but they can allways write it in such a way that it does fit but it's not likely that's true. However with your theory of Hurt being the guy who pushed the button it would have to be the Doctor. This is because he says:'He is me' when Clara asks who Hurt is. I know that the Doctor lies but it doesn't really make sense. Also Clara says she saw all his 11 faces which is once again a reference to the face. She then goes on to say he's the 11th Doctor but that can be explained by nobody except the Doctor knowing how many regeneration energy he still has left.--Drakonim ☎ 15:18, June 14, 2013 (UTC)
