Talk:The Choice (audio story)

From Tardis Wiki, the free Doctor Who reference
Revision as of 12:58, 14 October 2014 by Jlk7e (talk | contribs)

Sequel

This page is completely ridiculous. The story isn't "commonly mistaken" for a sequel to Warriors' Gate. It is a sequel to Warriors' Gate, with the serial numbers very imperfectly filed off. This whole wiki would be much better served by an "out of universe" approach that explains works in the context of the real world than by this absurd idea that you can fit all these stories into some kind of universal "Doctor Who Universe" which requires you to pretend that this story is not about Romana. Jlk7e 04:19, October 14, 2014 (UTC)

The key sentence is "However, BBV had no licence from the British Broadcasting Corporation to produce this series." Because they had no license, they can't make any claims to BBC stories. They can't claim that the character is Romana. It has nothing to do with fitting the story into a large narrative; it's a legal issue.
And the basic premise of this wiki is to fit all stories into a narrative. There's no way after 10 years and 40000+ articles that that's going to change. Shambala108 12:35, October 14, 2014 (UTC)
A) I understand that they can't claim that. But we are not BBV, and we can note the obvious fact that it's a story about Romana. B) The basic premise of this wiki is ridiculous. Jlk7e 12:58, October 14, 2014 (UTC)