It was agreed that there were three major points regarding the timelines that we wanted to discuss.
- 1. The default method of ordering stories with no other placement information. One suggestion is by release order, while another suggestion is a more random assortment of these stories.
- 2. The relationship between the main space pages for each of these characters and their respective timeline pages.
- 3. A complete overhaul of the Second Doctor's timeline.
The first two I have made headings for below, while the third will be on Theory talk:Timeline - Second Doctor. Danochy ☎ 00:45, April 3, 2020 (UTC)
Method for sorting stories
An expected result of these timelines is that there are a large number of stories which have no placement information relative to each other. My proposition is that the default ordering of such stories should be release order. An argument against this is that it is highly unlikely that the release order is the proper order, but any chosen random order is just as unlikely. The point is to find a sensible way of ordering stories, which release order fulfills satisfactorily. Danochy ☎ 00:45, April 3, 2020 (UTC)
I’d agree that release order should be implemented as a general rule. This would mostly be for stories with no other in-narrative suggestion of placement.
This doesn’t work in every medium however. Comics for example are serialised, and trying to order them by release outside of their own series can get messy, especially in relation to other comics. A recent example of this is the Titan and DWM Thirteenth Doctor Comics.
I think the main thing is just using discretion and knowing case by case, which stories would fit appropriately in release order and which ones might need to be moved about.
Another thing I’m interested in, is making the timelines as easy to navigate by visitors as possible. Right now I feel they’re a tad over complicated and it’s not so easy to find the exact information you might be looking for. SarahJaneFan ☎ 12:34, April 3, 2020 (UTC)
- A case-by-case basis makes sense, with the default being release order. I agree with that.
- What are your specific thoughts in terms of making it easier to navigate? I agree, but I'm not really sure what we could do. It does bring up another point, that I'd always liked the idea of: a spoiler free version of the page for individuals devising the best method to watch/listen/read without finding out major plot points along the way. It seems like a huge task to undetake, though, and an even bigger one to maintain. Danochy ☎ 01:21, April 4, 2020 (UTC)
- I don’t really have any specific strong ideas of how to make it easier to navigate but some small things like clearly titling certain eras so that if someone wants to find the Sixth Doctor’s post trial travels with Frobisher, it’s clear and easy to find from the index. Also again release order where possible tends to provide a bit more clarity and maybe trying to reduce or increase the amount of sections on a page because some seem to have way more than necessary and others need to be sorted into more digestible chunks in my opinion. Another thing is keeping the format of how stories are presented in the timelines consistent, particularly when it comes to flashbacks, references and smaller scenes separate from the main narrative as these tend to be presented inconsistently among users.
- The spoiler free timeline is a good idea although I’m not precisely sure how it could be implemented beyond creating a second page for each timeline which almost seems to be more hassle than it’s worth. It might be an idea to go through and remove any spoilers and plot points that aren’t necessary for placement in the timelines though. Listening/reading/watching order is of course another idea for an alternate take on the timelines as often you wouldn’t listen to Companion Chronicles in the order that the main story chronologically takes place. SarahJaneFan ☎ 02:36, April 4, 2020 (UTC)
Relationship between the main space and the Timey-wimey detector.
It was made pretty clear when this section of the forum was first created, that this was a place for theory and timeline talk doesn’t belong on the main page. This is of course because too much of it is speculation which is against the rules of the wiki mainspace and is only allowed to be implemented here in the theory section of the forum.
My main issue with, for example the Doctor timelines and the Doctor articles being edited to match up is due to how inflexible this makes editing the timelines themselves. Now the chronological order of stories in some cases has been limited by a placement based on where the particular story entries have been positioned on the main page. To me this is just wrong.
A biography doesnt have to be in chronological order, and timeline theory is expressly prohibited in the mainspace regardless. If people want to edit the order of the entries on the main page so that it matches the timeline page, then I’d say that that is their prerogative, but to limit the editing of a timeline page because it clashes with an entry on the mainspace is a step too far in my opinion.
The timelines change too often anyway to consistently keep track of it on the mainspace. People go to the main page to learn about the character, but they come here to discover the order of the stories. SarahJaneFan ☎ 12:45, April 3, 2020 (UTC)
- I agree, and if anything, the main space pages can be based on the timeline pages, at least in the cases where ordering doesn't matter. Danochy ☎ 01:17, April 4, 2020 (UTC)
My main concern as I’ve said is the restriction of editing to the timelines. I just think the emphasis on the relationship between the main page and the timelines should greatly reduced. Like there’s no rules saying they need to match, so if someone makes an edit, that shouldn’t be changed with reasoning that it causes issues with the layout of the main article. SarahJaneFan ☎ 02:18, April 4, 2020 (UTC)