Talk:The Time of Angels (TV story)

Rory

Since when was Rory in this episode? Can you please find some evidence for this because I have seen it nowhere. Doctormatthew 9:28, April 23, 2010 (UTC)

Spoilers!

just found this clip: www.youtube.com/watch?v=ECKMwGJNJLg It's from BBC America's 'Ultimate Guide' doc and it implies a few things about River Song in this episode, and what she already knows - Spoil a bit if you will, it's well confused me! Moffat's throwing us a few curve balls86.134.188.188 00:54, April 19, 2010 (UTC)

New Posters: If you make a post in the 'article' section, make sure everything is properly spelled and use proper grammer. Jedman67 02:17, April 21, 2010 (UTC)

I noticed that - I'd assume that whoever it was that went and changed the article (thank-you btw), they must have copied their spelling from the (now much older) comments on the link I posted (It was mainly Americans ;-)). I'd refrained from editing the article page because I'd considered it too much of a spoiler. There are no excuses for just copying someone else's spelling mistakes though. 86.134.188.188 19:45, April 24, 2010 (UTC)

Rumors about River Song: Source?

The following was posted in the main page under "Rumors":

1. In a recent interview with Alex Kingston It is said that in Silence in the Library/Forest of the Dead it is shown that River will have an intimate relationship with the doctor, meanwhile in The Time of Angels/Flesh and Stone, it is speculated that she will be a danger to the Doctor.

If you've seen a source, please post it! Thanks! - Jedman67 02:11, April 21, 2010 (UTC)

51st Century

There is mutiple points all over the page stating that either River Song is from the 51st century and/or the the episode is set in the 51st century but where is the actual sources??? until reliable ones are shown I'm removing them. -- Michael Downey 11:51, April 22, 2010 (UTC).

It's probably just someone making a tie-in with the rumors that she may be a Time Agent, and they're known to be based in/around the 51st century. MrCatharsis 21:30, April 23, 2010 (UTC)

The Doctor confirmed "it's the 51st century" when telling Amy that the Church has changed. Can someone update the page? 86.190.16.11 18:31, April 24, 2010 (UTC)#

I'm terrible with dates and stuff. Can someone remember to add in the century 12000 years in the future from the 51st century (that's the 63rd century isn't it) when the Doctor and Amy were in the museum. Mc hammark 19:24, April 24, 2010 (UTC)

Nope, 12000 years is 120 centuries (12 millennia), so that'll be 51+120 = the 171st century.

The Doctor did indeed say that they were in the 51st century when on the 'Weeping Angel planet'. But the Infobox needs editing. It says 51st century and 62nd century. The 62nd century would only be c. 6100--a 'paltry' 1100 years later; when, in fact, the Doctor and Amy were in the museum 12,000 years later (ie: the year 17,000). DigiFluid 08:01, April 25, 2010 (UTC)

Is she Patience?

In the episode when Amy Pond asks how she knows so much about how to fly a TARDIS, River says "I learned from the first one"...

This could imply she learned from the first Time Lord, which according to history was designated as Omega. This might also indicate she is Omega's (and the Other's) former-wife, Patience. Patience was last seen in Omega's anti-matter universe when it ceased to exist. (PDA: The Infinity Doctors)

She said she learned from the best, but that this wasn't the Doctor. What this actually means remains to be seen. Raven's wing 21:15, April 24, 2010 (UTC)

Also, while either Omega or the Other could conceivably have been "the best", it seems more likely that Rassillon would have had that honor, since he's the one who invented TARDISes. More importantly, both of them were presumably gone long before the era of the Type 40. --Falcotron 09:37, April 25, 2010 (UTC)

Or she could have just been teasing the doctor; which she isn't beyond doing; and did indeed learn from him. --Bluesilver 14:34, April 25, 2010 (UTC)

Amy Pond refererence to "sir"

Did anyone else notice that Amy referenced the fact that the Doctor never lets people call him "sir", even though (as far as I can tell) Amy has never been in an adventure where the Doctor has told someone not to call him "sir" or salute. Even if she has, certainly she has not been in enough adventures to know that he "never" lets people do it. Just an interesting aside.

Well, he could have mentioned it to her at some point. But actually, there's more interesting here than just the "sir".

In the scene before this one, the Doctor actually salutes the Bishop. It could be taken as a flippant salute, or as the kind of thing an impatient General gives to a staff officer, but either way, it's a far cry from (at least some) previous Doctors' explicit hatred of salutes. And, in that same scene, he accepts being called "the equivalent of an army" without flinching. And Amy doesn't see anything to comment on in either case.

However, in the following scene, when he lets the "sir" pass, he's clearly distracted at the time, with bigger things to worry about, and Amy sees this as significant enough to guess that "Whatever a Weeping Angel is, it's really bad."

So, the 11th Doctor has no problem with salutes, or with being called the equivalent of an army--or, for that matter, with being around lots of guns, or even asking for and firing one. But he does hate being called "sir".

Put all together, this is pretty interesting. Enlisted men hate being called "sir". And the higher in the (non-commissioned) ranks or the more specialized they get, the more they hate it. Trying calling a Sergeant Major, Staff Sergeant, or Commando "sir", and then order him to stop correcting you, and he'll flinch every time you say it. Of course a Sergeant Major would never give anything but a perfect salute (he's responsible for proper disciple of an entire unit), but the others are frequently involved in looser situations.

We know from Series 1 and from The Doctor's Daughter that the Doctor was "a soldier", and "on the front lines", sometimes involved behind enemy lines, and possibly at times operating pretty far outside of the normal chain of command and given considerable leeway (or, perhaps, taking considerable leeway, but then getting away with it). In other words, he's a special-forces Commando. --Falcotron 09:33, April 25, 2010 (UTC)

Spelling mistake on set

When Amy is standing beside the door of the Bishop's command pod, there is a warning on the wall about a "Trip Hazzard". There should only be one 'z' in hazard. 86.150.251.215 08:30, April 25, 2010 (UTC)

Page seems to be fully protected, and has tons of minor errors

I created an account just to fix all the minor errors of spelling, punctuation, etc., only to find out that, despite being marked as "semi-protected" it appears to be fully protected, so I still can't edit it.

In addition to the typos and grammar problems, there are a two (minor) substantive errors:

• When the Weeping Angel appears inside the dropship with Amy, there's no conclusive evidence that it's a hologram, but the article calls it one definitively.
• The Clerics are referred to definitively as "Christian soldiers". But, while the most obvious religious affiliations are Catholic of Anglican, the episode never makes it explicit that they're Christian at all (e.g., they talk about praying, but never mention Jesus). The fact that "Christian" is a sacred name might mean something--but then so is "Bob", and that doesn't prove that they're SubGenii.

So, someone who has permission might want to run this article through a spellchecker (and maybe a grammar checker), pick a consistent way to spell "Angelo", pick a consistent capitalization for "Cleric" and "Maze of the Dead", and rewrite the bits about holograms and Christians. --Falcotron 09:08, April 25, 2010 (UTC)

The Best

In [| this edit], Drwhobg added the following after the bit about fans speculating that "the best man [River] ever knew" referring to the Doctor:

This proved to be wrong, because when River responsed to Amy's question about piloting the TARDIS, she said that she learn from the best. The Doctor said shy "Well, yeah", thinking that River's talking about him. Anyway, Song said that she sorries that the Doctor was busy then. So, the best isn't the Doctor.

But there's no reason that the best TARDIS pilot/instructor and the best man she ever knew have to be the same person. In fact, the two statements have nothing to do with each other, except for sharing one word.

If I learned how to write optimized 3D graphics code from John Carmack, I'd say "I learned from the best," but that wouldn't mean he was the best man I ever knew. --Falcotron 12:01, April 25, 2010 (UTC)

Also, actually reading the added text, it's barely in English. --Falcotron 13:24, April 25, 2010 (UTC)

to someone who can edit this page: the section where it is discovered that the statues are all angels states that everyone turned to see that the statues had moved. I'm quite sure that the doctor turns off his torch to see if the statues move. this could do with correcting. also, the page needs to be spell checked. - Lu-igi board