More actions
Osgood's Mistake
I was watching the sequence where the Doctor boards the plane and enters the meeting room. When the joke about Valiant and Cloudbase is mentioned, Osgood instantly says that its from Thunderbirds and was corrected by Colonel Ahmed that it was from Captain Scarlet. Should that mistake of hers go here in the Continuity section or on Osgood's page?
Glasgow University
Edit: never mind. I was being really stupid. TheFartyDoctor Talk 00:07, November 9, 2014 (UTC)
Every nation's military?
Kate makes the clear statement that the Doctor, as President of Earth, is Commander in Chief of the armies of every nation. For a start, fifteen countries have no standing military force and I'm sure North Korea would not agree to it...
brigadiers deathdate
if this episode is right and it plays in the 2010ths that means that the brigadier died sometime between 2010 and 2020. thats clearly against every account for the brigadiers deathdate. – The preceding unsigned comment was added by 188.136.12.84 (talk).
- I think you might be confused, the only thing that matters in regards to the date of the Brigadier's death and the date of the episode is that his death has to have happened before this happened. There is nothing in the episode suggesting that he died after 2010, only that he died prior to it. Even if he did need to die after 2010 (which he didn't need to) didn't "The Wedding of River Song" have him die in 2011 which would place his death in that date range anyhow. - The Light6 ☎ 03:22, November 9, 2014 (UTC)
- And if you want to be strict about it, the Virgin New Adventures novels indicated that the Brigadier lived well past the mid-21st century due to some alien interference. However that's meaningless as this is Doctor Who and so he may have gone back in time at one point. 68.146.52.234talk to me 05:17, November 9, 2014 (UTC)
Four wives all deceased
Are you sure the Doctor's four wives include "Scarlette"? I'm not sure about the canonisation of the novel. Wouldn't the Doctor's first wife be whoever Susan Foreman's grandmother is? (or maybe the Tardis/Idris) Bathbomber ☎ 04:41, November 9, 2014 (UTC)
- This wiki takes into account all media. In the context of the TV series Moffat might have been leaving one open for later identification, or perhaps didn't count Marilyn at all given the Doctor didn't consider that a real marriage, but the expanded canon does have Scarlette, so barring a later episode giving an inventory, it's as valid as any other name. Does Clara actually say "deceased?" 68.146.52.234talk to me 05:19, November 9, 2014 (UTC)
- I stand corrected. I watched the episode again and Clara does indicate the wives are deceased. 68.146.52.234talk to me 19:20, November 9, 2014 (UTC)
Orson Pink, Clara's great grandson
If Danny is gone for good, does that mean that Clara is pregnant?
- This isn't the place to speculate about future episodes. 68.146.52.234talk to me 19:21, November 9, 2014 (UTC)
- It might, and it might not. We saw the Doctor's tomb that he was buried in during The Name of the Doctor, but history got changed and it turned out to be an alternate timeline. Who knows what's gonna happen. Stryzzar (talk) 10:16, November 15, 2014 (UTC)
Master's "death"
If "this isn't the place to speculate about future episodes" don't you think we're presuming a lot by saying at the top of the entry that Missy is dead? It's clear that the effect used for when she "disintegrates" is the exact same one used earlier in the episode when she teleports from place to place.
Tombstone
In the first scene where Clara is wandering around the graveyard, she passes by a tombstone marked "Born 1702 _ Died 1748", I was wondering if that belonged to an important character in the past. At first I immediately thought it was Victorian Clara Oswin Oswald, but the death date is 100 years off. Any ideas? Stryzzar ☎ 01:01, November 15, 2014 (UTC)
In this episode the Doctor says that he is not a good man, nor a bad man. This reminded me that in The night of the Doctor there is this conversation about being a good man: DOCTOR: I help where I can. I will not fight. OHILA: Because you are the good man, as you call yourself? DOCTOR: I call myself the Doctor. OHILA: It's the same thing in your mind. DOCTOR: I'd like to think so.
Amy and Rory
Do you think Amy pond and her husband Rory was turned into cybermen in this episode? i mean when the angels killed them they had a tombstone but its unknown if they were actually buried under it--0551E80Y ☎ 07:19, December 11, 2014 (UTC)
- Please note that, per Tardis:Discussion policy, article talk pages are for discussing the editing of articles, not speculation or theories. If you'd like to discuss this further, you can post a topic at Howling:The Howling. Thanks. Shambala108 ☎ 14:20, December 11, 2014 (UTC)
Flying Saucer
When the Doctor is being informed that he's now President of Earth, why in seven hells is he attempting to drink from the saucer rather than the teacup he was just shown tending to?
What if I write this.
Here's if I'd written this:
1. The Weapons-Grade Cybermen sound more as the Cybus one. And include a Cyber-Leader with black head-handles and a Cyber-Lieutenant with charcoal head-handles.
2. When Clara pretends to be the Doctor, she mentions past incidents of the Cybermen. And Dalek ones.
3. Clara reacts on shock to finding out Missy was the she-version of the Master she met when she met Adam Mitchell.
4. Rose stops Clara from shooting Missy with her psychic link. And scolds her for her hypocrisy. The 11th Doctor scolds her as well for her hypocrisy. And Skaldak reminds her how she stop him. And the War Doctor reminds her as well. And Davros mocks her for her hypocrisy and calls her a Dalek, as do many Daleks. Clara denies, only to hear a Dalek voice and see herself in a Dalek casing as in the Asylum. And Rose reveals it was her conscience telling her which she's doenw as wrong. And point out she slew Danny by putting ehr own needs above his and betraying the Doctor.
5. Missy can presuem Clara's gone mad. But then Rose speaks to Missy, and reveals she saw through her. And refus Missy's temptation to kill Clara for betraying the Doctor.