More actions
Proposed new name: Talk: Rose Tyler
Have links been moved? yes
 |
Archives: #1 |
|---|
Middle name
The only place I know of using the middle name "Marion" is a non-narrative article (not a story) in the Doctor Who Annual 2006. Is there anywhere else that says this? -- Tybort (talk page) 15:04, November 24, 2012 (UTC)
Shouldn't this information be mentioned in the article? DaPower ☎ 18:08, July 1, 2014 (UTC)
How many years did Rose travel with the Doctor For?
Seriously. Someone help me out with the math please. I know she was 19 when she joined him, but that's all I know. – The preceding unsigned comment was added by 24.4.226.205 (talk).
Living in/Travel to the Parallel World
I don't get the logic of why Rose and Jackie HAD to live in the parallel world. I mean, they might have preferred to live there because Pete Tyler was alive in that world. But just because Rose was thought to be dead in the real world was no reason why she would be forced to stay in the parallel world or had to return there after her visits back to the real world.
Also, why would it take a star to get an image of The Doctor speaking to Rose when she was first living in the parallel world but The Doctor, Donna, meta-crisis Doctor, Jackie and Rose later easily traveled to the parallel world in the TARDIS after the fight with Davros and the Daleks. The reality bomb was destroyed in the fight and shouldn't have affected travel between worlds.69.125.134.86talk to me 10:17, April 13, 2013 (UTC)
- We're talking post-Journey's End, right? Jackie went back there because she had a husband and a baby. The Doctor brought her back A) because he didn't want to separate her from her family, and B) to give the Meta-Crisis Doctor someplace to live and someone to look after him. All that was explained in that closing scene.
- Also, the Doctor had to use the star to power his hologram in Doomsday because there was only one small, closing crack between the two universes through which he could project himself. He could travel there in Journey's End because when the Reality Bomb went off in Pete's World (time running faster there, as a couple characters mentioned), it broke down the walls between the universes. The Doctor stopping Davros from detonating the bomb creates a ripple effect that makes that not happen - as DoctorDonna said, "dimensional retroclosure." TARDIStraveler ☎ 15:14, April 13, 2013 (UTC)
2.2 Updated with new information
I noticed that for Aliases that "The Valiant Child" was not included. Should that be added to this page? – The preceding unsigned comment was added by 108.7.49.171 (talk).
- No, because infoboxes are meant to be short, so we don't put nicknames and one-time names in the infobox. Thanks! Shambala108 ☎ 17:29, July 4, 2013 (UTC)
Behind the scenes
I've removed two items from the "Behind the scenes" section:
- Rose Tyler is the second longest serving companion of all time with 29 appearances as a companion.
I removed this one because it's too vague. If you're going to say "of all time", you have to take every companion in every appearance into account. "Appearances" is too vague — is it all stories, television stories, television episodes, NuWho stories, etc. If it can be clarified in some non-controversial way, it can be re-added. I say non-controversial because there have already been conflicting edits over whether Rose or Amy are the longest serving companions.
- Rose is the only companion to have an episode named after her. However, it could be argued that Martha Jones did as well; Martha's debut episode was called Smith and Jones. The "Jones" part was a reference to Martha's last name.
I removed this one because if one episode is named after Martha, then Rose is not the only one. There's no use in saying she's the only one to have an episode named after her first name. She's not the only, so this item shouldn't be re-added. Shambala108 ☎ 00:01, June 24, 2014 (UTC)
Adopted by Pete Tyler?
The current page lists the alternate universe Pete Tyler as Rose's "adoptive father". However, Rose is 19 when she's first introduced, which means she's legally an adult when she meets Pete. And you can't retroactively adopt an adult in the UK. Also, I don't remember it even being mentioned in any episode that Pete would've adopted Rose. So where does this information come from? – The preceding unsigned comment was added by 87.94.113.162 (talk • contribs) .
- Pete adopted her when Rose became trapped the alternate universe in Doomsday and confirmed such in Journey's End.– The preceding unsigned comment was added by Snivystorm (talk • contribs) .
Briggs and Dudman
Nicholas Briggs and Jacob Dudman provide narration for audio stories featuring Rose Tyler. Does this make them credible voice actors?
Thus far, the wiki has no official policy on the matter, the general response being that audios that are fully casted recasting the role and that portrayer being listed as a voice actor. In contrast, audios that are not fully casted use a narrator who reads in for absent actors as the character, the sole exception being if the character swap bodies, as the character narrating then is playing the other characters, as is the case for Damian Lynch in Ghost in the Machine, when his character, Benjamin Chikoto, switches bodies with Jo Grant and the Third Doctor.BananaClownMan ☎ 19:55, April 27, 2018 (UTC)
- Since this debate spreads across multiple pages already and will escalate in regard to the narration counts as actor situation should a yes or no be decided surely this is a topic best suited to the forums? Just a thought. --Borisashton ☎ 20:44, April 27, 2018 (UTC)
- Well, I see two pages for now. How about we agree to discuss it on Talk:Martha Jones for now? We can always move to the forum if need be later. Amorkuz ☎ 20:50, April 27, 2018 (UTC)
Korean Wiki
So I dunno what the policy is for this, but it seems the Korean Wiki has been closed. That's why the link to it looks like random lettering. Najawin ☎ 03:20, June 20, 2020 (UTC)
- Ah. Bugger. Now what an odd thing to happen. --Scrooge MacDuck ☎ 10:31, June 20, 2020 (UTC)