Theory:Doctor Who television discontinuity and plot holes/The Ark: Difference between revisions

Theory:Doctor Who television discontinuity and plot holes/The Ark (edit)

Revision as of 19:02, 10 April 2013

423 bytes added , 10 April 2013

Added counter-arguments

Craigysa

219

edits

@@ Line 2: / Line 2: @@
 *It's rather remarkable that the TARDIS manages to land in the same spot twice (albeit a few years apart) when the Doctor can't control its journey.
 ::The Doctor forgot to enter new spacial coordinates, or there was a breakdown in the mechanism, and only the time circuits were activated for this journey. This being the case, the TARDIS followed its default/emergency procedure (See [[TV]]: ''[[Terminus (TV story)|Terminus]]'') of remaining locked-on to the Ark as a 'fixed point', even though it would have moved billions of miles through space in the intervening centuries it took to reach Refusis.
-:::Alternatively, given the recent revelations in ''[[The Doctor's Wife]]'', the TARDIS may have realised that the Doctor was partially responsible for causing the Monoids to overthrow the guardians, and taken him to the future because that is where he "needed to go" to put things right.
+:::Actually the background changes so much that it is unlikely that the TARDIS landed in the exact same spot.
+::Alternatively, given the recent revelations in ''[[The Doctor's Wife]]'', the TARDIS may have realised that the Doctor was partially responsible for causing the Monoids to overthrow the guardians, and taken him to the future because that is where he "needed to go" to put things right.
+::First, The Doctor had no particular intention of returning to the ship, so that is somewhat irrelevant to the question. That said: (a) Is it remarkable? Yes. (b) Is it an amazing coincidence? Possibly (c) Unless it was part of some grander scheme/influence. (d) However, is it a discontinuity? Absolutely not.
 [[Category:DW TV discontinuity]]