Trusted
34,029
edits
User:OttselSpy25/Commercial fiction sandbox (edit)
Revision as of 21:08, 20 March 2023
, 20 March 2023→Stories I'm less certain about
OttselSpy25 (talk | contribs) Tag: 2017 source edit |
OttselSpy25 (talk | contribs) Tag: 2017 source edit |
||
| Line 42: | Line 42: | ||
* [[Doctor Who: 50 Years (trailer)]] - Another great example here where there's no real proof that this was intended to be set inside the ''DWU''. But you could also argue that this trailer simply depicts a [[Multi-Doctor Event]] that ''Day'' doesn't show. It's certainly more of a promotional short than a trailer, and certainly something that would qualify for ''Rule 4 by Proxy'' if some other valid fiction referenced it. But as it stands, I think it deserves to be in the middle here. | * [[Doctor Who: 50 Years (trailer)]] - Another great example here where there's no real proof that this was intended to be set inside the ''DWU''. But you could also argue that this trailer simply depicts a [[Multi-Doctor Event]] that ''Day'' doesn't show. It's certainly more of a promotional short than a trailer, and certainly something that would qualify for ''Rule 4 by Proxy'' if some other valid fiction referenced it. But as it stands, I think it deserves to be in the middle here. | ||
* ''[[WeLoveTITANS]]'' - I think as these were disqualified for being commercials, they might justify another debate, but I just don't know how many people WANT to go down that rabbit hole again | * ''[[WeLoveTITANS]]'' - I think as these were disqualified for being commercials, they might justify another debate, but I just don't know how many people WANT to go down that rabbit hole again | ||
* [[Doctor Who and the Ambassadors of Death (trailer)]] - A little unsure about this. I | * ''[[Time Is Everything (TV story)|Time Is Everything]]'' - Presuming we revoke the widespread ban on advertisements, this would be a contender for coverage. The only hiccup is the fourth-wall breaking, which is an issue we've long gotten older but have never codified in a debate. The ''DWU''ness of this has also never been contended, but if it was the only thing standing in the way of this being valid I'm sure someone would change their minds, so this probably needs its own debate. | ||
* [[Doctor Who and the Ambassadors of Death (trailer)]] - A little unsure about this, I've gone back-and-forth on it and it's difficult to make a call without this in front of me. I don't want to set the precedent that old footage with a new framing device is always a trailer. But I also wouldn't put up a fight for this unless someone else wants to as well. | |||
* [[Death of the Doctor (trailer)]] - Also the same situation | * [[Death of the Doctor (trailer)]] - Also the same situation | ||