885
edits
More actions
no edit summary
V00D00M0NKY (talk | contribs) No edit summary |
No edit summary |
||
| Line 49: | Line 49: | ||
:::Theory? Theory. We have been proposing that the Doctor may or may not have appeared as new and old Doctor in Flesh and Stone. And he told Amy to remember. Remember what? I think it might be Rory. But why would he tell her before she knew what it was about? Well, simply because if she was told AFTER they had joined with Rory, she would have forgotten all about it. She would have forgotten it because it was about Rory. But - if she remembers - how will Rory have lived? Because Rory will have lived up until that point on the hillside. Amy mentions she thought she saw another person - residual memory? Or a memory fighting to become truth? We never see exactly what happens to Rory - he may be lost, he may not. Moffat has been telling us all season that time doesn't work the way we think it does. Maybe this is what he means. [[Special:Contributions/219.90.240.172|219.90.240.172]] 14:52, May 30, 2010 (UTC) | :::Theory? Theory. We have been proposing that the Doctor may or may not have appeared as new and old Doctor in Flesh and Stone. And he told Amy to remember. Remember what? I think it might be Rory. But why would he tell her before she knew what it was about? Well, simply because if she was told AFTER they had joined with Rory, she would have forgotten all about it. She would have forgotten it because it was about Rory. But - if she remembers - how will Rory have lived? Because Rory will have lived up until that point on the hillside. Amy mentions she thought she saw another person - residual memory? Or a memory fighting to become truth? We never see exactly what happens to Rory - he may be lost, he may not. Moffat has been telling us all season that time doesn't work the way we think it does. Maybe this is what he means. [[Special:Contributions/219.90.240.172|219.90.240.172]] 14:52, May 30, 2010 (UTC) | ||
:::"Remember what I told you when you were 7." And you say that he was talking about Rory there? You think the Doctor told Amy about Rory when she was 7? [[User:V00D00M0NKY|V00D00M0NKY]] 21:17, May 30, 2010 (UTC) | :::"Remember what I told you when you were 7." And you say that he was talking about Rory there? You think the Doctor told Amy about Rory when she was 7? [[User:V00D00M0NKY|V00D00M0NKY]] 21:17, May 30, 2010 (UTC) | ||
::::V00D00M0NKY, I was mostly agreeing with you on #3 (and I agreed with you so completely on #1 that I didn't have anything to add), but elaborating on it. The "I think you've got a different conception..." bit was to the twelfth doctor's original question/complaint, not to you. | |||
::::Anon IP guy, in FaS, as V00D00M0NKY said at the same time I was trying to type this (damn you for being more concise and faster! :)), unless he first told her at 7 to remember Rory, and then told her in FaS to remember that he'd told her to remember Rory, that doesn't really work. And that would be really odd and convoluted, wouldn't it? Certainly being told to remember Rory at 7 would have affected her life up until The Beast Below far more than it would affect her afterward. Especially since, if that's what he was doing, we know that it didn't work, because CB was later in her timeline, and she couldn't remember him. | |||
::::But it could be something sort of similar. Maybe he told her about how time travel affects your timeline, gives you a choice to remember things the original way, etc. This could have helped her in FaS in some way that we couldn't directly see at the time, and will also help her to bring Rory back in The Big Bang, I suppose. --[[User:Falcotron|Falcotron]] 21:22, May 30, 2010 (UTC) | |||