Talk:Melody Pond: Difference between revisions

Talk:Melody Pond (edit)

Revision as of 02:40, 1 May 2011

1,413 bytes added , 1 May 2011

→‎The Impossible Astronaut

Looq

60

edits

@@ Line 143: / Line 143: @@
 *end of ''[[Day of the Moon]]'':
 **'''[[Eleventh Doctor]]:''' See you next time, call me!
 *start of ''[[The Pandorica Opens (TV story)|The Pandorica Opens]]'':
 **'''[[Eleventh Doctor]]:''' You graffitied the oldest cliff face in the universe.
 **'''[[River Song]]:''' You wouldn't answer your phone.
-Simple enough, I think.  [[User:Witoki|Witoki]] 22:41, April 30, 2011 (UTC)
+Simple enough, I think. [[User:Witoki|Witoki]] 22:41, April 30, 2011 (UTC)
+I think its fair enough to say that the current order it reversed, but it might not always be the case for two simple reasons:
+) The Diaries wouldn't work. If the order was perfect reverse for each, they would only be in sync in exactly the middle of each of their personal timelines (think about it). So if it was a perfect reverse order there would be no point to them whatsoever, because there would be no events in the Doctor's that would be in River's as the same time (except for the above example). For the an event to be in both their pasts then they must meet out of (reverse) order some of the time. We know this because they use the diaries to match up specific events, rather than saying "this was the last thing I did with you". Although the order is clearly ''generally ''reversed.
+) We have know of two specific out of order events:
+A) River has not been given the Doctor's Sonic Screwdriver from our perspective; therefore a Doctor from our future must contact a River from our past (i.e. between Silence in the Library and The Time of Angels). I believe it was the "picnic as asgard" where their timelines seemed to be in sync (his last meeting with her, and her second to last meeting with him).
+B) The FutureDoc10 from the begining of the Impossible Astronaut, who seemed to be "in-sync" with the River of that time (unlike the PresentDoc10 to whom River is still a fairly new companion).
 == Punctuation ==