Forum:River Song incarnations or full page?: Difference between revisions

Forum:River Song incarnations or full page? (edit)

Revision as of 22:11, 1 September 2011

1,392 bytes added , 1 September 2011

→‎Further discussion: Responses

Rassilon of Old

54

edits

@@ Line 81: / Line 81: @@
-I suspect that people think that extra pages reflects a character's importance, just like calling them a companion. I like River Song.  I like the way Mr. Moffat has written her and her  various incarnations and the way the actresses have portrayed her. In many ways, she speaks for the people around here who love the doctor and still see his warts. However, it's still more convenient, when trying to find out something about her, not to have to shuffle back and forth among various hyperlinks. [[User:Boblipton|Boblipton]] 19:14, September 1, 2011 (UTC)
+I suspect that people think that extra pages reflects a character's importance, just like calling them a companion. I like River Song. I like the way Mr. Moffat has written her and her various incarnations and the way the actresses have portrayed her. In many ways, she speaks for the people around here who love the doctor and still see his warts. However, it's still more convenient, when trying to find out something about her, not to have to shuffle back and forth among various hyperlinks. [[User:Boblipton|Boblipton]] 19:14, September 1, 2011 (UTC)
+: Yes, I saw the banner, but to be honest, I didn't think it was really a spoiler, I mean the wiki has spoilers of casting hosted in the mainspace. And yes, it isn't very reliable, hence the italics I employed when I said she was confirmed.
+: Yes, she is primarily known as River Song, not just by the viewers, but even the Doctor continues to call her River in "[[Let's Kill Hitler]]". And while that is the third incarnation's name, it is not the first or the second's name, which are Melody and Mels respectively. It's not a matter of what the fans prefer, it's a matter of cold hard facts, and the fact is, that her name is Melody Pond.
+: And to that nony talking about the Master's various incarnations, I apologise that I can't address that, as I've not seen much of Classic Who, except for Hartnell's first three serials, and Baker's first story.
+: And to Revan, I don't think it does sit comfortably, it looks messy and unorganised. I will try to neaten it up a little, and reassess the issue then, but it doesn't look neat or tidy at all in my opinion.
+: Boblipton, if you wanted to find out something about her, you could just read the 'umbrella page', as it's being called, for a quick overview. If you wanted to actually read more in-depth information about her, you would go to the respective incarnation's article. {{User:Rassilon of Old/Sig}} 22:11, September 1, 2011 (UTC)