Talk:Doctor Who Comes to MINECRAFT! (webcast)

Trailer

There is not, and never has been, a rule on this wiki saying that trailers must be explicitly identified as such. This is a ludicrous red herring. The issue is simple, the description of the video says:

We are very excited to announce that Doctor Who will be coming to Minecraft officially!

And goes on to list details. The definition of a trailer is to advertise something by broadcasting excerpts or details - as both the video and the description do. This is a trailer. (Note that I'd love for there to be a MC DW video, I find that hilarious, this has nothing to do with my personal preference. This just is a trailer. It's honestly a little surreal to me that there's a discussion.) Najawin ☎ 21:02, 5 September 2022 (UTC)

Hang on now; as a matter of policy, you're wrong. There is such a policy, or at least such a precedent. The borders between "prologues", "prequels", "trailers" and so on have become so porous that the only standard for whether a given story is a trailer is whether it is called a trailer in its marketing; which this isn't. So it isn't.

Thing is, though, there are still such things as narrative commercials, even ones that are not trailers as the Wiki understands the term. And per current T:VS, they cannot be valid on principle. This does look a heck of a lot like one of those. It'd be one thing if it were a single, continuous narrative clip, but here we have disconnected snapshots of various Doctors and companions doing various thing, with no clear overarching story or premise. It looks a lot more like one of the LEGO Dimensions trailers made up of cleaned-up gameplay footage than it does like, say, Listen to the voice of your Master! or even Cyberon is Back!! (two notable examples of things not called trailers that one might be tempted to call trailers naively, but whose validity is tangibly justified by both being specifically referenced by the narrative of the things they were "promotional prequels" for).

There is also a more general Rule 4 discussion to be had — even if it were a regular narrative webcast with no question of promotion, is this really intended to take place in the Doctor Who universe? The lack of any multiverse-talk, or indeed any particular narrative justifications for all the Doctors being here and able to pull bows out of thin air and walk on the same, leads me to think this just isn't meant to be a narrative about the "real" Doctors, commercial or not.

So I lean towards this being not technically a trailer, but still {{invalid}} on more general Rule 4 grounds. Scrooge MacDuck ⊕ 21:08, 5 September 2022 (UTC)