204
edits
Talk:The End of Time (TV story)/Archive 1: Difference between revisions
From Tardis Wiki, the free Doctor Who reference
Talk:The End of Time (TV story)/Archive 1 (edit)
Revision as of 11:07, 15 February 2010
, 15 February 2010→Heavy edit to Discontinuity section
m (→The End of Time (TV Story): misapplied talk page template. This section is definitely appropriate to a talk page) |
Ben Paddon (talk | contribs) |
||
| Line 1,222: | Line 1,222: | ||
*If the woman who speaks to wilfred is a time lady, which we know because she is seen with rassilon, indicating she was in the time war, and the doctor was said to have destroyed every time lord and dalek in the war, how could she meet wilfred? and if she is dead, exactly how could she return and come to see wilfred? ''(How she managed to contact Wilfred is intentionally left unexplained for the time being.)'' | *If the woman who speaks to wilfred is a time lady, which we know because she is seen with rassilon, indicating she was in the time war, and the doctor was said to have destroyed every time lord and dalek in the war, how could she meet wilfred? and if she is dead, exactly how could she return and come to see wilfred? ''(How she managed to contact Wilfred is intentionally left unexplained for the time being.)'' | ||
lottie01 00:20, January 29, 2010 (UTC) | lottie01 00:20, January 29, 2010 (UTC) | ||
:The Plot Holes section is incredibly bloated, filled with supposed "holes" that are explained within the episodes themselves. I mean, honestly: | |||
::''"When Wilfred is trapped in the radiation chamber, why couldn't the Doctor leave and come back with a teleportation device, some other means to repair the chamber, or even a radiation suit of some kind? Perhaps even replicate the TARDIS effect he used in DW: The Doctor Dances to rescue Jack Harkness from his exploding ship?"'' | |||
:Come ''on.'' The bloody thing's ''overloading.'' That's not a "Wait right here, I'll be back in an hour" scenario. Who bloody put ''that'' in? | |||
::''"Why did Sarah Jane Smith create a cover story for Gallifrey heading towards Earth when everyone is very aware of the existence of alien life by these events?"'' | |||
:Luke says why. In the episode. Immediately after he says what Mr. Smith has done. ''Immediately after he says what Mr. Smith has done.'' | |||
::''"The Doctor said "even then, it feels like dying" when he tells wilfred about the prophecy and regeneration, yet he should feel like he is being revitalized when he renegerates. So, why would it feel like dying?"'' | |||
:Someone wasn't listening to the Doctor's lines here, I think. | |||
::''"The Doctor knew he was going to regenerate from the minute he saved Wilfred from the radiation. He had seemed to accept this. But the minute before he actually did regenerate, he was starting to cry and said "I don't wanna go." Why would he say this if he had accepted his fate? "'' | |||
:In what parallel universe is ''this'' a continuity error? | |||
:I won't go on, but the stuff that's been left in as "Discontinuity, Plot Holes, Errors" is of shockingly poor quality and is in dire need of an overhaul. --[[User:Ben Paddon|Ben Paddon]] 11:07, February 15, 2010 (UTC) | |||
== russel t davies build up == | == russel t davies build up == | ||
