Theory talk:Timeline - Sixth Doctor: Difference between revisions
From Tardis Wiki, the free Doctor Who reference
→Comic Strips order: the legitimacy of "Stripped For Action?": new section
SarahJaneFan (talk | contribs) Tag: 2017 source edit |
Tag: 2017 source edit |
||
Line 163: | Line 163: | ||
I just got finished listening to Series 3 and 4 of ''Jago & Litefoot'', and I think that those stories are placed ''way'' too late in the Sixth Doctor's timeline. The Doctor in these stories is shown as being irritable and somewhat flippant about the loss of human life like he was before he met Evelyn. I'm not sure if the placement of this story was based on the fact that the Doctor is shown wearing a blue suit on the cover of ''The Hourglass Killers,'' but not only is that very clearly not the same blue suit, he was incognito during his time in Victorian London in order to hide from Kempston and Hardwick. I'm going to move these stories to right before he met Evelyn. –[[User:Nahald|Nahald]] [[User talk:Nahald|<span title="Talk to me">☎</span>]] 02:30, 8 April 2021 (UTC) | I just got finished listening to Series 3 and 4 of ''Jago & Litefoot'', and I think that those stories are placed ''way'' too late in the Sixth Doctor's timeline. The Doctor in these stories is shown as being irritable and somewhat flippant about the loss of human life like he was before he met Evelyn. I'm not sure if the placement of this story was based on the fact that the Doctor is shown wearing a blue suit on the cover of ''The Hourglass Killers,'' but not only is that very clearly not the same blue suit, he was incognito during his time in Victorian London in order to hide from Kempston and Hardwick. I'm going to move these stories to right before he met Evelyn. –[[User:Nahald|Nahald]] [[User talk:Nahald|<span title="Talk to me">☎</span>]] 02:30, 8 April 2021 (UTC) | ||
== Comic Strips order: the legitimacy of "Stripped For Action?" == | |||
I'm very much a casual contributor to the wiki and as such am very unfamiliar with the rules and agreed-upon policies in regards to what is considered a valid source for chronological order. I was therefor wondering whether or not ''[[Stripped for action?]]'' could be cited as reason for the chronological order of the Sixth Doctor comic strips in the same way that ''[[Interweaving with the New Adventures]]'' often is. I realise that the order proposed by ''Stripped'' contradicts some parts of the current timeline but as far as I'm aware, so does ''Interweaving'' and its still cited for several story placement. | |||
This here is the order as per ''Stipped for Action?'', btw: | |||
*'''''[[The Twin Dilemma (TV story)|The Twin Dilemma]]''''' | |||
*'''''[[Attack of the Cybermen (TV story)|Attack of the Cybermen]]''''' | |||
*'''''[[Vengeance on Varos (TV story)|Vengeance on Varos]]''''' | |||
*'''''[[The Mark of the Rani (TV story)|The Mark of the Rani]]''''' | |||
*'''''[[The Two Doctors (TV story)|The Two Doctors]]''''' | |||
*'''''[[Timelash (TV story)|Timelash]]''''' | |||
*'''''[[Revelation of the Daleks (TV story)|Revelation of the Daleks]]''''' | |||
:Peri takes a break from travelling in the TARDIS. | |||
:*''[[The Shape Shifter (comic story)|The Shape Shifter]]'': [[Frobisher]] joins | |||
:*''[[Voyager (comic story)|Voyager]]'' | |||
:*''[[Polly the Glot (comic story)|Polly the Glot]]'' | |||
:*''[[Once Upon a Time-Lord (comic story)|Once Upon a Time-Lord]]'' | |||
:*''[[War-Game (comic story)|War-Game]]'' | |||
:*''[[Funhouse (comic story)|Fun House]]'' | |||
:*''[[Kane's Story (comic story)|Kane's Story]]'' (Various titles): Peri re-joins the Doctor | |||
:*''[[Exodus (comic story)|Exodus]]'' | |||
:*''[[Revelation! (comic story)|Revelation!]]'' | |||
:*''[[Nature of the Beast! (comic story)|Nature of the Beast!]]'' | |||
:*''[[Time Bomb (comic story)|Time Bomb]]'' | |||
:*''[[Salad Daze (comic story)|Salad Daze]]'' | |||
:*''[[Changes (comic story)|Changes]]'' | |||
:*''[[Profits of Doom! (comic story)|Profits of Doom!]]'' | |||
:*''[[The Gift (comic story)|The Gift]]'' | |||
:*''[[The World Shapers (comic story)|The World Shapers]]'': [[Jamie McCrimmon|Jamie]] joins but, an old man, he is killed on [[Marinus]] | |||
*''[[The Nightmare Fair (TV story)|The Nightmare Fair]]'' (Proposed Season 23) | |||
*''[[The Ultimate Evil (TV story)|The Ultimate Evil]]'' (Proposed Season 23) | |||
*''[[Mission to Magnus (TV story)|Mission to Magnus]]'' (Proposed Season 23) | |||
*'''''[[The Trial of a Time Lord]]''''' | |||
:Peri leaves. Mel joins the Doctor, somehow. | |||
So, as far as I know, the release order (at least, for the strips). I know that the strips are basically still in that order on the page but I'm just wondering if it'd be ok to cite ''Stripped'' as a reason for those placements instead of the (sometimes) unreliable release order alone. |