Trusted
34,029
edits
User:OttselSpy25/Validity topics: Difference between revisions
From Tardis Wiki, the free Doctor Who reference
→Topics
OttselSpy25 (talk | contribs) Tag: 2017 source edit |
OttselSpy25 (talk | contribs) (→Topics) Tag: 2017 source edit |
||
| (10 intermediate revisions by the same user not shown) | |||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
== Topics == | |||
=== Have completed OPs === | |||
# Removing the blanket ban on What If stories | |||
# Charity Stories that are TECHNICALLY licensed... | |||
# Infidel's Comet | |||
=== Am generally considering === | === Am generally considering === | ||
# ''[[Do You Have a Licence to Save this Planet? (home video)|Do You Have a Licence to Save this Planet?]]'' - No one wants to give BBV more coverage, we're all tired of it. But this is one of the cases where you could make a clear case for the video. | # ''[[Do You Have a Licence to Save this Planet? (home video)|Do You Have a Licence to Save this Planet?]]'' - No one wants to give BBV more coverage, we're all tired of it. But this is one of the cases where you could make a clear case for the video. | ||
# ''[[Doctor Who Pinball: Time Streams]]'' / ''[[Time Streams (video game)|Time Streams]]'' - In my top 4 "Things that should be valid" hot-takes. If I include this in a group post, it should be the only "long" one, since people could disagree with me and there's no reason to overwhelm people. | # ''[[Doctor Who Pinball: Time Streams]]'' / ''[[Time Streams (video game)|Time Streams]]'' - In my top 4 "Things that should be valid" hot-takes. If I include this in a group post, it should be the only "long" one, since people could disagree with me and there's no reason to overwhelm people. | ||
| Line 10: | Line 12: | ||
## This is a weird one because it seems so extremely minor but it could have massive implications if we do it wrong. Might just be too much for a speed round. | ## This is a weird one because it seems so extremely minor but it could have massive implications if we do it wrong. Might just be too much for a speed round. | ||
# ''[[Extras: The Special (TV story)|Extras: The Special]]'' - So I do not want this valid, I think it should be non-valid. But I think the way we cover it just isn't fun. This story is non-valid for being a fictional episode of ''Doctor Who'' inside of another TV show. But I think editors in the non-valid space could be able to add this info to, say, [[Tenth Doctor/Non-valid sources]], and not just [[David Tennant/Non-valid sources]]. | # ''[[Extras: The Special (TV story)|Extras: The Special]]'' - So I do not want this valid, I think it should be non-valid. But I think the way we cover it just isn't fun. This story is non-valid for being a fictional episode of ''Doctor Who'' inside of another TV show. But I think editors in the non-valid space could be able to add this info to, say, [[Tenth Doctor/Non-valid sources]], and not just [[David Tennant/Non-valid sources]]. | ||
# ''[[Devious (home video)|Devious]]'' - Arguing for coverage but not validity. | |||
# [[Gwanzulum]] extended universe | |||
## ''[[Combat Colin Versus The Gwanzulums (comic story)|Combat Colin Versus The Gwanzulums]]'' (Transformers/Action Force #160 - 163) | |||
## ''[[Double Jeopardy! (comic story)|Double Jeopardy!]]'' (''Thundercats'' #66 - 67) | |||
## ''[[Too Many Ghost Busters! (comic story)|Too Many Ghost Busters!]]'' (Ghostbusters #9) | |||
## ''[[Ghostbusters' Fact File: Gwanzulums (feature)|Ghostbusters' Fact File: Gwanzulums]]'' (Ghostbusters #20) | |||
=== things I've ruled out === | === things I've ruled out === | ||
# [[Special Executive]] stories - but only ones which feature Wardog, Cobweb, and Zeitgeist (mmaaaaaybe Fascination) - This is already being covered. No need to kick a hornest's nest. | |||
# ''[[Billy Smart's Children's Circus (TV story)]]'' - Seems to go with the Proms. Could use a debate but it feels silly to debate things we don't even have pages on. | |||
# [[Special Executive]] stories | |||
