Howling:River Song is a....... MAJOR SPOLIERS!!!: Difference between revisions
From Tardis Wiki, the free Doctor Who reference
Howling:River Song is a....... MAJOR SPOLIERS!!! (view source)
Revision as of 06:22, 6 July 2010
, 6 July 2010no edit summary
No edit summary |
No edit summary |
||
| Line 103: | Line 103: | ||
:Nope, can be anyone, but definitely can't be Rory...in the Big Bang, the "best man" has already been murdered, and when River saw the Big Bang's timeline's Auton Rory, she doesn't know who he is and calls him "oh...the Nestene duplicate..."...and she thought he were evil too...so doesn't really make sense to be the "best man"....[[Special:Contributions/222.166.181.12|222.166.181.12]] 15:24, July 3, 2010 (UTC) | :Nope, can be anyone, but definitely can't be Rory...in the Big Bang, the "best man" has already been murdered, and when River saw the Big Bang's timeline's Auton Rory, she doesn't know who he is and calls him "oh...the Nestene duplicate..."...and she thought he were evil too...so doesn't really make sense to be the "best man"....[[Special:Contributions/222.166.181.12|222.166.181.12]] 15:24, July 3, 2010 (UTC) | ||
::While I agree that Rory probably isn't the 'best man,' your reasoning makes little sense to me. The 'best man' dying, afaik, didn't cause some catastrophic event. So his death then is irrelevant, especially since he is brought back (and could be killed again). And River is hardly the most trustworthy person around, so taking her exclamations or lack thereof as proof of anything is foolish. She's pretty evasive towards most questions. The Doctor didn't seem upset by her killing of the Dalek out of revenge, after it pleaded for mercy. Why? Because she being the only witness probably left out that detail. [[User:Vegnas|Vegnas]] 00:23, July 6, 2010 (UTC) | ::While I agree that Rory probably isn't the 'best man,' your reasoning makes little sense to me. The 'best man' dying, afaik, didn't cause some catastrophic event. So his death then is irrelevant, especially since he is brought back (and could be killed again). And River is hardly the most trustworthy person around, so taking her exclamations or lack thereof as proof of anything is foolish. She's pretty evasive towards most questions. The Doctor didn't seem upset by her killing of the Dalek out of revenge, after it pleaded for mercy. Why? Because she being the only witness probably left out that detail. [[User:Vegnas|Vegnas]] 00:23, July 6, 2010 (UTC) | ||
::How did you know there were even a 'good man' then, Bishop and River could have lied? How did you know the Doctor is the Doctor; he is certainly most untrustworthy, he could be some chav boy on the street that stole the TARDIS and modified his biology using a chameleon arch...I think there is a difference between random guessing and speculative...Is Rory still alive a really strong support to make it speculative? | |||
::Writers don't write in reactions to mislead...actors act 'actions' they don't act reactions...writing in fake reactions would be extremely bad writing... | |||
::When you are being chased by a Dalek and the world is ending in 20 mins, I don't think anyone would be very good at making up lies about the first thing you see... | |||
::I haven't seen anyone saying that the murdering of the 'good man' didn't cause any catastrophic event...I know nothing about the murder yet...I would be glad if you could point me to the source.... | |||
::I might have missed it, but I actually can't even remember if the Doctor knew that River Song killed the Dalek...the world is ending and the Doctor is about to sacrifice himself, it didn't sound like exactly the best time to share every single detail of you killing a random Dalek[[Special:Contributions/203.168.176.42|203.168.176.42]] 06:22, July 6, 2010 (UTC) | |||
:Oh yeah. That's true. Well that's a relief anyway. Don't think I could cope with Rory dying again![[Special:Contributions/81.141.81.0|81.141.81.0]] 18:00, July 3, 2010 (UTC) | :Oh yeah. That's true. Well that's a relief anyway. Don't think I could cope with Rory dying again![[Special:Contributions/81.141.81.0|81.141.81.0]] 18:00, July 3, 2010 (UTC) | ||
:Let's hope Moffat don't make this into a running joke and kills Rory whenever there seems to be too little going on...[[Special:Contributions/203.168.176.42|203.168.176.42]] 05:05, July 4, 2010 (UTC) | :Let's hope Moffat don't make this into a running joke and kills Rory whenever there seems to be too little going on...[[Special:Contributions/203.168.176.42|203.168.176.42]] 05:05, July 4, 2010 (UTC) | ||
: | : | ||
:How about she could be another Time Lord and she is the person who kills the 12th Doctor to leads to the 13 Doctor (Matt Smith is the 11th doctor but only the 10th regenieration) | :How about she could be another Time Lord and she is the person who kills the 12th Doctor to leads to the 13 Doctor (Matt Smith is the 11th doctor but only the 10th regenieration) | ||
