Forum:UNIT aren't really companions: Difference between revisions

Forum:UNIT aren't really companions (edit)

341 bytes added , 8 August 2011

no edit summary

emailconfirmed, Administrators

43,565

edits

@@ Line 19: / Line 19: @@
 It's not for the wiki to decided upon the definition. You need an in-universe source for complete clarity as even the opinion someone like JNT isn't gospel. Not sure why you're saying a trip in the TARDIS is on the companion check-list. [[Liz Shaw]] is a companion, is she not? Yet she only travels in the TARDIS in ''[[The Wages of Sin]]''.--{{User:Skittles the hog/sig}} 11:48, August 8, 2011 (UTC)
-I personally don't count the UNIT soliders as companions, but, I '''Do '''count Liz Shaw as a companion because she is the same as a companion throughout season 7. I don't count the Brig because he's at most a friend of the doctor (if he was a companion why isn't he listed as a companion in "The Web of Fear"?)
+I personally don't count the UNIT soliders as companions, but, I '''Do '''count Liz Shaw as a companion because she is the same as a companion throughout season 7. I don't count the Brig because he's at most a friend of the doctor (if he was a companion why isn't he listed as a companion in "The Web of Fear"?){{Unsigned|Joe.kearney}}
+Because his appearances in ''[[The Web of Fear]]'', ''[[The Invasion]]'', ''[[Terror of the Zygons]]'' and ''[[Battlefield]]'' (etc. ?) are just one-offs. In season 7, he is in every story and seems to do a damn sight more for the Doctor than Liz ever did.--{{User:Skittles the hog/sig}} 15:31, August 8, 2011 (UTC)