Talk:Sil: Difference between revisions
From Tardis Wiki, the free Doctor Who reference
(Created page with "==Placement of Mission to Magnus== Is it possible that, in Sil's own timeline, ''Mission to Magnus'' happened before the events of ''Mindwarp''? I only ask this because his li...") |
(→Bulbasaur?: new section) |
||
| (3 intermediate revisions by 3 users not shown) | |||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
==Placement of Mission to Magnus== | ==Placement of Mission to Magnus== | ||
Is it possible that, in Sil's own timeline, ''Mission to Magnus'' happened before the events of ''Mindwarp''? I only ask this because his line in ''Mindwarp'' "Age has not improved you since Varos" seems to imply that this is his first time meeting the Doctor and Peri since then. –[[User:Nahald|Nahald]] [[User talk:Nahald|<span title="Talk to me">☎</span>]] 06:19, June 24, 2020 (UTC) | Is it possible that, in Sil's own timeline, ''Mission to Magnus'' happened before the events of ''Mindwarp''? I only ask this because his line in ''Mindwarp'' "Age has not improved you since Varos" seems to imply that this is his first time meeting the Doctor and Peri since then. –[[User:Nahald|Nahald]] [[User talk:Nahald|<span title="Talk to me">☎</span>]] 06:19, June 24, 2020 (UTC) | ||
: I doubt it. The denizens of [[Theory:Timey-wimey detector]], or some other one of the many places on the Internet where people choose to think that ''Doctor Who'' timelines can be linear, are free to make up their own answer, of course. But the line in ''[[Mindwarp (TV story)|Mindwarp]]'' seems simply to be a function of the fact that as far as was known at the time, the Doctor and Sil ''hadn't'' met before. ''[[Mission to Magnus (TV story)|Mission to Magnus]]'' the TV story wasn't "canonical" because it literally didn't exist, not because they had some other timeline placement in mind. | |||
: Now, you could argue that ''[[Mission to Magnus (novelisation)|Mission to Magnus]]'' the novel, and/or ''[[Mission to Magnus (audio story)|Mission to Magnus]]'' the audio story, may have been intended to occupy a difference place in the Doctor's timeline than the TV story was supposed to. But I doubt it. Both adaptions were marketed as the faithful translation of "the lost episode"; therefore it seems clear one is meant to mentally slot it into Season 23, just like magic. | |||
: There are, as I said, many stories which dispute the idea that trying to solve these kinds of minor contradictions by moving stories wholesale up and down the timeline is a good idea. ''[[Bafflement and Devotion (short story)|Bafflement and Devotion]]'', which establishes that in a complicated metatemporal way, new adventures are perpetually being retroactively added to the Doctor's past (in a direct mirror to retcons & "Past Doctor Adventures" in the real world), seems the most relevant. | |||
: As was reaffirmed earlier this year for the placement of [[Sacha Dhawan]]'s Spy Master on [[The Master]], the Wiki's stance that timeline theories belongs in [[Theory:Timey-wimey detector]] means that unless ''clear'' in-universe evidence and authorial intent are present, we should assume that a character's appearances in an ongoing stories happen in the right order for them and for the Doctor. --[[User:Scrooge MacDuck|Scrooge MacDuck]] [[User talk:Scrooge MacDuck|<span title="Talk to me">☎</span>]] 09:47, June 24, 2020 (UTC) | |||
::I'm more talking about Syl's timeline than the Doctor's though. Yes _Mission to Magnus_ obviously takes place before _Mindwarp_ in the Doctor's timeline, but is there any reason to suspect that this is how these vents unfolded chronologically in Syl's life? –[[User:Nahald|Nahald]] [[User talk:Nahald|<span title="Talk to me">☎</span>]] 03:30, June 25, 2020 (UTC) | |||
::: Not sure about the novel, but Sil claims he moved to [[Magnus (planet)|Magnus]] right after Varos: | |||
:::: SIL: After your meddling caused the failure of my Varos project, I was ordered to drum up new business here. | |||
::: [[User:Danochy|Danochy]] [[User talk:Danochy|<span title="Talk to me">☎</span>]] 03:34, June 25, 2020 (UTC) | |||
== Bulbasaur? == | |||
I understand the statistics in the citizen file in ''Sil and the Devil Seeds'' are lifted straight from Bulbasaur's statistics in the Pokémon series. But why are we treating Bulbasaur itself as valid information? As far as I can see from the screenshot of the profile, it doesn't say anything about Bulbasaur. [[User:WaltK|WaltK]] [[User talk:WaltK|<span title="Talk to me">☎</span>]] 18:43, 26 June 2023 (UTC) | |||
Latest revision as of 18:43, 26 June 2023
Placement of Mission to Magnus[[edit source]]
Is it possible that, in Sil's own timeline, Mission to Magnus happened before the events of Mindwarp? I only ask this because his line in Mindwarp "Age has not improved you since Varos" seems to imply that this is his first time meeting the Doctor and Peri since then. –Nahald ☎ 06:19, June 24, 2020 (UTC)
- I doubt it. The denizens of Theory:Timey-wimey detector, or some other one of the many places on the Internet where people choose to think that Doctor Who timelines can be linear, are free to make up their own answer, of course. But the line in Mindwarp seems simply to be a function of the fact that as far as was known at the time, the Doctor and Sil hadn't met before. Mission to Magnus the TV story wasn't "canonical" because it literally didn't exist, not because they had some other timeline placement in mind.
- Now, you could argue that Mission to Magnus the novel, and/or Mission to Magnus the audio story, may have been intended to occupy a difference place in the Doctor's timeline than the TV story was supposed to. But I doubt it. Both adaptions were marketed as the faithful translation of "the lost episode"; therefore it seems clear one is meant to mentally slot it into Season 23, just like magic.
- There are, as I said, many stories which dispute the idea that trying to solve these kinds of minor contradictions by moving stories wholesale up and down the timeline is a good idea. Bafflement and Devotion, which establishes that in a complicated metatemporal way, new adventures are perpetually being retroactively added to the Doctor's past (in a direct mirror to retcons & "Past Doctor Adventures" in the real world), seems the most relevant.
- As was reaffirmed earlier this year for the placement of Sacha Dhawan's Spy Master on The Master, the Wiki's stance that timeline theories belongs in Theory:Timey-wimey detector means that unless clear in-universe evidence and authorial intent are present, we should assume that a character's appearances in an ongoing stories happen in the right order for them and for the Doctor. --Scrooge MacDuck ☎ 09:47, June 24, 2020 (UTC)
Bulbasaur?[[edit source]]
I understand the statistics in the citizen file in Sil and the Devil Seeds are lifted straight from Bulbasaur's statistics in the Pokémon series. But why are we treating Bulbasaur itself as valid information? As far as I can see from the screenshot of the profile, it doesn't say anything about Bulbasaur. WaltK ☎ 18:43, 26 June 2023 (UTC)
