Talk:Melody Pond (The Impossible Astronaut): Difference between revisions

From Tardis Wiki, the free Doctor Who reference
(→‎Title: Unlikely)
 
(17 intermediate revisions by 6 users not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
== Title ==
{{ArchiveList}}
== Rename ==
I agree with [[User:Tybort|Tybort]]'s suggestion in the rename template that the story dab on this page should be changed to (The Impossible Astronaut) – the [[Virgin New Adventures]] have already given us many examples of characters who technically appeared first in the DWM prequels but are nonetheless disambiguated by the novel title; [[Luigi (Blood Harvest)]] is one example I found with a few seconds of searching. The same precedent should apply here, and to the extent that the current text of the rules doesn't match this longstanding practice, the rules [[Forum:Temporary forums/T:BOUND Reform|should be updated]]. – [[User:NateBumber|n8]] ([[User talk:NateBumber|☎]]) 15:01, 24 August 2023 (UTC)


Should this page not be called "Melody Pond (Little Girl)"? She is referred to in the show as 'Little Girl', whereas calling her the 'Spacesuit' incarnation seems a bit silly. '''[http://doctor-who-collectors.wikia.com/wiki/User:Tardis1963 <span style="background:#0E234E; color:white">Tardis1963</span>]''' 08:31, August 28, 2011 (UTC)
:I too agree with this suggestion. [[User:Aquanafrahudy|<span style="font-family: serif; color: pink" title="Hallo." > Aquanafrahudy</span>]] [[User talk: Aquanafrahudy|<span title="Talk to me">📢</span>]] 15:43, 24 August 2023 (UTC)
 
:: This has been open for a long while, and the VNA precedent is inarguable, now it's been laid out. Performing rename. To be clear, the ruling here is that these sorts of short-form prequels, unless they constitute a narrative that could stand on its own, should be considered part of their parent stories when it comes to dabbing elements in them.{{User:SOTO/sig}} 03:40, 30 March 2024 (UTC)
: I actually opened the talk page to suggest this, so yes, definitely. {{User:Rassilon of Old/Sig}} 13:44, August 28, 2011 (UTC)
::: I agree with the ruling ''per se'', but for the record "unless they constitute a narrative that could stand on its own" doesn't feel like the right standard. Most of these things ''could'' easily be covered as standalone if the longer thing didn't exist. It's all about presentation. --[[User:Scrooge MacDuck|Scrooge MacDuck]] [[User talk:Scrooge MacDuck|<span title="Talk to me"></span>]] 12:36, 30 March 2024 (UTC)
::Agreed--"spacesuit" just sounds pathetic. I vote that we simply move this page to something like "Melody Pond (Little Girl)", as suggested above. --[[User:Bold Clone|<span style="color:darkblue">'''Bold'''</span>]] [[User Talk:Bold Clone|<span style="color:gold">'''Clone'''</span>]] 19:49, August 28, 2011 (UTC)
 
I think 'Little Girl' or even 'The Impossible Astronaut' (That seems to be what Kovarian called her) Or maybe just Melody Pond. Another question should be asked though, Since Mels said that she first regenerated as a toddler... Well she is not really a toddler here, so does that mean she regenerated earlier than this? {{SUBST:Template:Cyrus Arc}} 20:15, August 28, 2011 (UTC)
:I concur that these page should be at "Melody Pond (Little Girl)" – I would be BOLD myself, but I can't find the move button... [[User:Danbarnesdavies|DBD]] 22:28, August 28, 2011 (UTC)
No idea where the move button has gone, so if an admin or someone could move this page to "Melody Pond (Little Girl)", that'd be great. '''[http://doctor-who-collectors.wikia.com/wiki/User:Tardis1963 <span style="background:#0E234E; color:white">Tardis1963</span>]''' 09:05, August 29, 2011 (UTC)
 
: As clarification, the line Mels delivered during her regeneration scene in "Let's Kill Hitler" was "Last time I did this, I ended up a toddler, in the middle of New York!" So the little girl is Melody's first incarnation, as far as she can remember, and this then makes Mels her second incarnation, unless she regenerated twice in New York, which I'm going to deem as unlikely. {{User:Rassilon of Old/Sig}} 07:12, August 30, 2011 (UTC)

Latest revision as of 12:36, 30 March 2024

Archive.png
Archives: #1

Rename[[edit source]]

I agree with Tybort's suggestion in the rename template that the story dab on this page should be changed to (The Impossible Astronaut) – the Virgin New Adventures have already given us many examples of characters who technically appeared first in the DWM prequels but are nonetheless disambiguated by the novel title; Luigi (Blood Harvest) is one example I found with a few seconds of searching. The same precedent should apply here, and to the extent that the current text of the rules doesn't match this longstanding practice, the rules should be updated. – n8 () 15:01, 24 August 2023 (UTC)

I too agree with this suggestion. Aquanafrahudy 📢 15:43, 24 August 2023 (UTC)
This has been open for a long while, and the VNA precedent is inarguable, now it's been laid out. Performing rename. To be clear, the ruling here is that these sorts of short-form prequels, unless they constitute a narrative that could stand on its own, should be considered part of their parent stories when it comes to dabbing elements in them.
× SOTO (//) 03:40, 30 March 2024 (UTC)
I agree with the ruling per se, but for the record "unless they constitute a narrative that could stand on its own" doesn't feel like the right standard. Most of these things could easily be covered as standalone if the longer thing didn't exist. It's all about presentation. --Scrooge MacDuck 12:36, 30 March 2024 (UTC)